Drone attacks: a separate issue
Monday, May 25, 2009
By Gul Bukhari
Monday, 25 May, 2009
PRIOR to the All-Parties Conference of May 18, Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani is said to have been apprehensive regarding the stance that right-of-centre and religious parties could take.
The leaders of some of these parties had indicated at the outset that they would endorse continued military action against extremist militants in the Malakand division only if the Pakistani government took a firm stance on the issue of drone attacks in the Fata area.
From the draft document of the APC resolutions, as well as subsequent dissenting statements in the media by the Jamaat-i-Islami, Tehrik-i-Insaaf, Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam (JUI) and a few other parties, it’s apparent that Mr Gilani’s concerns were on the money. Clearly, unequivocal support of the military operation, the cause célèbre of the conference, is nowhere to be seen in the resolution!
Instead, expressions of grief, reaffirmation of commitment to sovereignty of state and constitution, safety and wellbeing of the internally displaced persons, appreciation of sacrifices of people etc form the bulk of the draft. Very noble, no doubt, but lacking concrete endorsement of military action against violent extremists.
Interestingly, one article of the draft resolutions condemns ‘the violation of Pakistan’s political, economic and territorial sovereignty including drone attacks’. Thus in conformity with their reported promised position on drones vis-à-vis backing the military operation, the same political parties have publicly condemned and called for a halt to the military action in Malakand post the APC. By extension, they see the entire war as America’s war and still recommend ‘negotiations’ with the Taliban.
Given that there are extensive arguments on record in support of the operation in Malakand, and it enjoys wide public support, it would be more pertinent to touch on the more complicated and emotive issue of the drones instead.
Drone attacks inside Pakistan by the US are an issue. However, the idea that these attacks are, or should be, linked to an endorsement of, or detraction from, an indigenous counter-terrorism policy is incomprehensible. Our leaders need to be very clear in their minds that the issue of sovereignty of the country is a completely different one from that of fighting a known, recognised, tried and tested enemy within. Those mixing up the two issues need help understanding why the two are, and must be kept, separate.
First, how will halting the military operations, or not backing any indigenous anti-terror policy, stop the drone attacks? Logically, not conducting an operation should spur the US to intensify the attacks rather than the opposite.
Secondly, not continuing to back the ongoing operations and allowing the militants to consolidate and continue their struggle to seize countrywide control, is akin to cutting your own nose to spite another’s face i.e. letting Pakistan burn to spite the US. Not a shred of sense is visible here.
The only mad glimmer of reasoning could be that it would be Pakistan thumbing its nose at America, ‘hey, see my suicide jacket? I will blow myself up if you don’t stop punching me, and you’ll be left behind cleaning up the mess I make with my bloody remains all over the region.…’
Having said this, the issue of the drones makes for a curious case in terms of evolution of the governmental stance. Over the past year and a quarter, the position has evolved from denial of the existence of attacks, to not having any bases within the country or lack of ability to put a stop to them to a final lack of will.
Ironically, having condemned violation of the country’s sovereignty continuously, including at the APC, the prime minister and his government are now reported to be in a dilemma vis-à-vis the US reaction if Pakistan were to actually take strong action, for example cutting Nato supply lines to stop the drone attacks. The fear being that the international community, led of course by the US, might in retaliation withdraw promised aid for the IDPs. This too is a bizarre connection to make.Firstly, the US is very unlikely to try and lead such an embargo out of public image concerns if nothing else. The current US administration has been seen to be at pains to improve its image worldwide, especially amongst Muslim nations. To refuse or actively impede aid, in the face of an enormous and burgeoning humanitarian crisis being beamed around the world, would rob the US of any moral high ground in terms of world opinion.
Secondly, the IDPs issue has gained recognition domestically and internationally as being one of the key factors that will determine continued public support for the war in Malakand. As a result it is being increasingly named as one of the biggest factors that will play a hand in whether this war can be extended to its logical conclusion. So, from a strategic perspective as well, can the US reasonably be expected to shoot itself in the foot by actively and vindictively precipitating further the IDPs humanitarian crisis, almost ensuring Pakistan’s defeat in the war against violent extremism?
Washington’s immediate goal is to crush the militancy in Fata. The drones are only a tool towards that end. It would not make any logical sense for the US not to see the wood for the trees.
It is critical to understand that drone attacks are a sovereignty issue. The war in Malakand is an issue of fighting an internal existential threat. Whether the government decides to take a firm stance on the drone attacks or not the support for this war will continue, since public support is based on considerations of self-preservation. It would be beyond foolishness to try and link the two.
Similarly, the aid issue is also a red herring. If the government isn’t able or willing to force a halt to drone attacks for whatever reason, the IDPs and their welfare should not be made the excuse. Either the state needs to take visible steps clearly in its power to stop the drone attacks, or take honest political ownership of them.
Instead of creating and pandering to misconceptions and false linkages the government and other national leaders need to help clarify issues and lead from the front.
Source
Labels: APC, Drone Attacks, IDPs, Militants, Swat Operation, Taliban, Terrorism, US Pakistan Relations
posted @ 11:14 AM,
,
![]()
Time to dump allies
Sunday, May 24, 2009
By Asha’ar Rehman
Sunday, 24 May, 2009
THE people in government must embarrass themselves as they strive to perpetuate their stay in power. The ones billed as their replacement may only be slightly less acrobatic and less amusing in their antics. The gymnastics show is so repetitive that we would have gone crazy by now had we not learnt to laugh it off.
As usual, the latest democratic run coincided with vows of reconciliation and greater tolerance among the politicians. The quality of politics has suffered seriously in the melee that has followed in the subsequent 16 months or so. Just think it over: it’s been days since anyone talked about the sacred Charter of Democracy here.
In a statement that appeared in Friday’s papers, Nawaz Sharif has categorically reported that all political forces are behind the military operation in Swat. His is a heartening statement but the reasons cited behind it are varied. It is obvious that good old Mian Sahib is going to come under pressure from many of his old allies for having dragged them into this front that he is currently in the process of building. At any rate, the politician, the pivot of civilian rule and civilian supremacy the famous CoD celebrated and pledged to nurture, appears to be the least plausible cause behind the PML-N leadership’s sudden change of mind.
The record substantiates the suspicion. The politician — the leader, the worker — has died a hundred deaths in the war against the extremists. ANP rallies have been bombed and party members besieged, PPP gatherings have been blown up, while others have not only watched from a distance but have actually, to borrow a recent original expression from Ahsan Iqbal, tried to get political mileage out of the situation. The same politicians are now aghast when they are at the receiving end of uncharitable remarks of JI chief Munawwar Hasan.
‘PML-N reacts strongly to JI allegations’ read the headline to a news item carried by Lahore papers last week. How long have we waited for this bit to come for we knew all along that given the demands generated by an earnest push for power this was inevitable.
“The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz … dismissed as ridiculous Jamaat-i-Islami chief Munawwar Hasan’s statement that it had changed its stance on national issues to appease the United States….” was the introduction to the story. “ In a written statement, PML-N information secretary Ahsan Iqbal said his party needed no ‘certificate of patriotism’ from Hasan.”
Mr Iqbal was quoted as saying that “the PML-N had always taken a clear and categorical stance on all national issues, which is evident in the growing popularity of the party’s top leadership...” and that “… some religious political parties were unfortunately trying to gain political mileage through hypocrisy” (reference to JUI-F) and that “this … was not the time for political point-scoring; political forces should rather help the government steer the country out of the prevailing crises….”
In case someone was looking for consistency, the statement was rounded off with the PML-N refrain on just how unreliable the federal government is in carrying out the wishes of the all-parties’ conference (APC) on Swat.
The APC widened the fissures within the right. It ‘formally’ pitted the ones who are sensing a return to government against those who are not in the run for power and can thus afford to take principled stands.
The gulf will increase with time. Others will come forward to fill the void created by the PML-N’s departure from the anti-imperialist camp. Life will continue. We know what best some of us can do in times like these: wish for a third force to emerge.
Those fed up with the system are once again making noises that the incumbents and pretenders must lend an ear to. There has been a series of small incidents that tell the populace that even the gods in the PML-N may have feet of clay. Even though he has escaped the public condemnation of Justice Dogar’s daughter, an N-League lawmaker from Rawalpindi has been pulled up for examination fraud; there is an inquiry pending against the Punjab prison minister on the allegations of breaking customs rules; and while the fiery rights activists are yet to tear him apart in front of the camera, an N-League member of the Punjab Assembly has been named in a torture case.
Right now the PML-N may — one more time — dump unwanted allies like the JI, it may sacrifice a few errant members of its own to maintain the high moral ground that it has been holding. The party will find it harder to make similar sacrifices the closer it finds itself to the seat of power in Islamabad. And it has treaded the path frequently enough to not be talking about the Charter of Democracy and principles any more.
Source
Labels: APC, JI, JUI(F), Militants, PML(N), Swat Operation, Taliban, Tehreek-e-Insaaf, Terrorism
posted @ 10:38 AM,
,
![]()
Split on the Taliban
Sunday, May 24, 2009
Analysis, Dr Hasan-Askari Rizvi
Militancy and terrorism are so deeply entrenched in Pakistan that the government and the military will need to deal with it on different fronts over a long period of time
The May 18 All-Parties Conference on Swat approved a ‘compromise’ resolution to accommodate the sensitivities of some political parties. The unanimous resolution condemned violent challenges to the state of Pakistan and its constitution. It emphasised the need for preservation and protection of the constitution and state structures, and also called upon everybody to work for the safety and well being of the refugees from the conflict zones.
However, the resolution did not mention the Swat operation. Nor did it directly endorse or require its closure. Similarly, the Taliban were neither condemned nor were they asked to give up arms. No reference was made to the role of the United States in Afghanistan and its fallout on Pakistan, although some leaders criticised the US in their speeches.
The APC manifested a split in the political class on the issues of the Swat operation and the Taliban. The major divide is between the Islamist parties and most of the others; the former opposing the Malakand operation at the APC. Post- APC, they have been either defending the Taliban or engaging in a virulent campaign against the military operation, blaming it for the suffering of the ordinary people. These parties are appealing to religious emotions by arguing that Pakistan’s Muslim army is killing its own Muslim citizens.
Islamist parties never made such statements when various militant groups executed civilian and military personnel in public, hanged the dead bodies of clerics from trees, bombed barber and music shops, burnt down girls’ schools, flogged people in public and launched suicide attacks.
Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e Insaf is the only party that is not labelled as Islamist but it opposes military action and sympathises with the Taliban.
The PPP, the ANP, the MQM and the PMLQ are very categorical in their support for the military operation. Other political parties also support these efforts. It can be safely argued that most of the political class is supportive of the efforts to check religious extremism and militancy, especially the efforts to dislodge the Taliban from Malakand. Such support also exists at the popular level, although people are deeply concerned about the problems of the refugees and want them to return to their homes in safety at the earliest.
The Taliban’s fatal mistake was their interpretation of the agreement between the TNSM and the NWFP provincial government as their victory and a sign of the government’s weakness. Therefore, Sufi Muhammad declared Pakistan’s constitution, parliament, democracy and the judicial system as un-Islamic, began to drag his feet on the selection of qazis and asked the regular courts to wind up their work in Swat.
On the other hand, the Taliban led by Fazlullah, moved their fighters to take control of the adjoining areas. Some government officials were kidnapped and the Taliban adopted aggressive posture even within the Swat valley.
These developments forced the NWFP and federal governments to change their disposition towards the TNSM and the Taliban. A large section of the public realised that the Taliban do not believe in a negotiated and peaceful resolution of the problem, and instead want to establish their authority at the expense of the Pakistani state.
Further, taking a cue from the defiance of Sufi Muhammad and the Swat-based Taliban, their denominational allies began to assert themselves selectively in cities like Lahore and Karachi.
This perturbed large sections of civil society, which was not associated with any political party, causing a major shift in public opinion in favour of stern action against the militants.
PMLN chief Nawaz Sharif argued at the APC that tough action must be taken to control terrorism and that the military operation should be taken to its logical end without giving any concessions to extremists and terrorists. His support was very reassuring for the government.
However, Sharif’s statement could not remove ambiguity about the PMLN’s stance on the Taliban. Prior to the APC, some of Sharif’s leading lieutenants took the government to task in the National Assembly for launching the military operation. Even after Sharif’s statement of support, PMLN parliamentarians Saad Rafiq and Ahsan Iqbal were not willing to support the Swat operation. Chaudhry Nisar Ali khan and Khwaja Asif were also not in favour of military action to control the Taliban menace.
The divergent perspectives of PMLN leaders reflect their desire to simultaneously pacify different foreign and domestic interests. Nevertheless, the PMLN position recognises the threat, and distinguishes itself from Islamist parties that defend the Taliban in an unabashed manner.
Jama’at-e Islami leaders are orchestrating a campaign against the Swat operation, describing it as a threat to Pakistan’s solidarity. The PPP-led coalition government is the main target of the Jama’at’s criticism and, at times, the army is also taken to task for “killing Muslims and country-men”. Pro-JI elements in the media are also quite active in advancing the Jama’at’s perspective.
The JUIF is part of the ruling coalition but its chief, Maulana Fazlur Rahman, is also critical of the Swat operation, though he does not want to quit the coalition on this issue. Other Islamist parties are also critical of the Swat operation. However, their appeal has no relevance beyond their members and supporters.
Islamist elements are facing an internal divide based on denominational differences. Religious leaders and groups subscribing to the Deobandi/Ahle Hadees/Wahabi Islamic traditions are generally supportive of the Taliban. They want the Swat operation to be stopped and the government to negotiate with the Taliban. They also view the Taliban as friends of Pakistan, and argue that if the government stops pursuing American agenda in the region, the trouble between the Taliban and the government would come to an end.
This perspective is rejected by most religious leaders from the Barelvi Islamic tradition, who want tough action against the Taliban. This group argues that the Taliban have adversely affected the reputation of Islam and thus cannot be allowed to enforce their version of Islam by coercion. Followers of the Shia tradition also share the Barelvi perspective on the Taliban. This division has weakened the clout of pro-Taliban Islamist parties and religious leaders.
The government and military authorities are determined to subdue the Taliban in Malakand because both are convinced that these elements cannot be allowed a free rein to expand their domain and threaten people.
The Swat operation is a turning point in Pakistan’s official disposition towards religious extremism and militancy. Pakistan will no longer tolerate such activity. However, militancy and terrorism are so deeply entrenched in Pakistan that the government and the military will need to deal with it on different fronts over a long period of time. If they stand firm in their resolve and succeed in subduing the Taliban, Islamist opposition will wither away.
Source
Labels: APC, Militants, Swat Operation, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 10:29 AM,
,
![]()
APC unanimity
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
In an unusual demonstration of harmony, all the major political parties in the country backed the operation in Swat. The loud chorus in favour of the move against militants meant that the feeble voice of dissent raised by several religious parties and the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf was more or less completely drowned out. For the government this marks a big success. The strong backing of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz proved finally to be the key factor in swinging the balance and ensuring that no notable voice of opposition was heard. From the APC, it seems clear that all major parties in the country have recognized there is no choice but to battle militants with all the might we can muster. This is an important development for several reasons; The end to the dichotomy of opinion, as far as mainstream forces go, on how to handle the Taliban should help build support for our soldiers entrenched in battle in the north. The confusion over the need for them to do so should indeed end. The APC verdict will help achieve this with major political leaders making it clear there is no doubt in their minds as to what is needed and why.
The meeting also represented a forum where, perhaps for the first time, leaders also spoke out against those opposing the military operation. Their silence suggests they had few answers to give. Indeed some seem to have been persuaded as to the right of what was happening, with Imran Khan finally signing the joint declaration after ANP leaders answered questions that he put to them, claiming confusion over issues linked to the operation. In a state of civil war, it is always useful for either side to have public opinion behind it. The considerable force of this opinion seems now to be moving against the Taliban. Whether they have come about by accident or design, the events of the past few months have played a part in making this possible. The militants have been discredited, they have been increasingly exposed as mindless savages and this has played a part in the building of the consent we now see. The fact that it coincides with news of major military successes is also welcome and should help secure the victory that does not seem too far away.
But all the political parties, and the rest of us too, need to keep in mind that this may not be the final triumph. A great deal will still need to be done to ensure the victory is a lasting one. As we move into this phase, we will need the parties to come forward with their thoughts and ideas and to act as a kind of pressure group on government. We must then hope all the political players are looking too towards this future, and are ready to play their part in building one that would ensure peace and security for the people of the northern areas and also those in other parts of the country.
Labels: APC, Militants, Swat Operation, Taliban, Terrorism, Tribal Areas
posted @ 1:13 PM,
,
![]()
APC endorses Swat operation PML-N’s clear stand silences dissenters
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
By Ahmad Hassan
Tuesday, 19 May, 2009
ISLAMABAD, May 18: The government and the military on Monday got the much-needed backing from the country’s political class and, barring a few minor exceptions, leaders of political parties from across the broad spectrum supported the efforts to eliminate the menace of religious extremism and terrorism, but cautioned against collateral damage or alienation of the general public.
Perhaps the biggest, and much-needed, support came from Mian Nawaz Sharif and his Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N) which proved to be the moot point in the shaping of opinion during the All Parties Conference called by Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani.
In fact, the support from the main opposition party in a way compelled some of the opposition groups, particularly the Jamaat-i-Islami, Imran Khan’s Tehrik-i-Insaaf and Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam either to take a back seat or to dilute their criticism of the ongoing security operation against the Taliban in Swat and adjoining areas.
If there was any doubt about the PML-N’s position at the conference, Mr Sharif’s closest lieutenant Raja Zafarul Haq came out to declare that the party had fully backed the military operation in the Malakand region.
Later talking to DawnNews, Mr Haq said that if similar conditions prevailed in the Waziristan region, his party would not hesitate to support a military operation there as well.
Premier Gilani had convened the APC to discuss the ongoing military operation and evolve a joint strategy.
And despite some reservations expressed by a few of the relatively smaller parties and groups, the APC succeeded in adopting a joint declaration which, in essence, supported government’s efforts to restore peace and constitutional rule in the troubled region of Malakand and beyond.
The APC attended by leaders of 43 major political and religious parties discussed in details the situation arising out of the activities of militants and extremists in parts of the NWFP that forced the government to undertake military action.
It was one of those rare events in the country’s politics where almost every politician and party that matter were present at the Prime Minister’s House, not only to express their views on one of the gravest situations faced by the country since the fall of Dhaka, but also to try and evolve a consensus on meeting the challenge.
So right from the prime minister and other senior members of the PPP-led government to Nawaz Sharif, and Jamaat leaders to those from the two JUIs, and Mehmood Khan Achakzai and Aftab Ahmed Sherpao to Asfandyar Wali Khan and Imran Khan and Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain to those from the MQM were all present to deliberate on the matter.
A few of them, though arch rivals and real adversaries in politics, not only shook hands and exchanged pleasantries but in the end also agreed to a joint declaration.
Inside sources told Dawn that a majority of the leaders had endorsed the government’s decision to launch the military operation after exhausting all other options, including the so-called Nizam-i-Adl regulation.
According to them, JI, JUI-S, PTI and JUI-F leaders expressed their reservations over the military action.
Talking to reporters after the conference, JI leader Liaquat Baloch said his party had impressed upon the government that the use of military might should have been avoided.
Perhaps Sheikh Rasheed Ahmed described the decision more aptly when he said: “Majority of the participants supported the military action and no one opposed it.”
Prime Minister Gilani informed the leaders that the military operation was proceeding successfully and the army would remain in the region till peace was restored and displaced people were able to return to their homes.
He, however, said the military operation was not a permanent solution, adding: “Unless political forces step in to resolve the situation, there is no guarantee to a sustainable solution (of the problem of terrorism and extremism).”
He said the army action had become necessary after the militants refused to acknowledge the writ of the state, treated innocent people with brutality and made their lives miserable.
“It was, therefore, decided to call in the army in the best national interest and for the safety of our own people,” he said, adding that rehabilitation of IDPs was as important as the military action.
He said: “The government will leave no stone unturned for their rehabilitation and for reconstruction of damaged property. We are determined to defeat every conspiracy being hatched in the name of Islam.”
Nuclear assets
The prime minister rejected a perception that Pakistan’s nuclear assets would fall into the hands of militants and said that nuclear assets were safe and anyone daring to compromise these would be dealt with severely.
A 16-point resolution unanimously adopted at the APC resolved to strive to unite the nation in the face of insurgency in Swat and Malakand, struggle collectively for security and welfare of the IDPs and to jointly combat terrorism, extremism and sectarianism.
The following is the text of the resolution:
1. Recalled, the consensus resolution passed by a joint sitting of parliament on October 22, 2008;
2. Reiterated, its support of the resolution passed on October 2, 2008, and the subsequent recommendations made by the parliamentary committee on national security as required by the resolution and impressed upon the need for speedy implementation;
3. Reaffirmed, its commitment to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and sovereignty of the state of Pakistan;
4. Emphasised, the need to establish and maintain the writ of the state and ensure supremacy of the rule of law;
5. Condemned, all violent challenges to the Constitution and the state of Pakistan;
6. Expressed, grief for the martyrdom of security personnel and innocent civilians;
7. Maintaining, that the safety and security of civilians is paramount and it should be ensured that minimum harm is caused to the non-combatant civilian population;
8. Re-emphasised, the need to ensure the safety, wellbeing and rehabilitation in their respective areas of the internally displaced persons;
9. Called upon, the Pakistani people to respond as one nation to mitigate the suffering of our brothers and sisters, the Internally Displaced Persons;
10. Emphasised, that Pakistan is a vibrant dynamic democracy;
11 Reaffirmed, that Pakistan’s nuclear assets were under an effective command and control authority;
12 Asserted, that the strategic decisions regarding military issues, including troops’ deployment, are the sole prerogative of the state of Pakistan;
13. Appreciated, the tremendous sacrifices given by the Pakistani people economically, politically and in terms of human life while fighting terrorism, more than any other country or people;
14. Condemned, the violation of Pakistan’s optical economic and territorial sovereignty, including drone attacks; and
15. Conveyed, that Pakistan is a sovereign state and any aid, economic or military which carries cardinalities will be counter-productive.
Labels: APC, Militants, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 11:57 AM,
,
![]()
APC: a ‘second thoughts’ conference?
Saturday, May 16, 2009
May 16, 2009
On Monday, the government will try to persuade the opposition inside and outside parliament that the military action in Malakand Division should be allowed to go on. Before that our army chief General Ashfaq Kayani would have given them an in-camera briefing on how the military operations in FATA and Malakand are faring, after the army’s earlier declaration that the Taliban no longer control any area.
The APC has been convened after a strident demand made “in retrospect” by the opposition inside a parliament that has apparently changed its mind for the third time. The APC call was ignored when the parliament supported the military operation last week. But after the refugees started pouring out of Swat and other places, the mood changed back to the APC. So what will be the intent behind the APC?
Normally a government risks an APC when it knows that it will obtain a policy consensus out of it. If this consensus is not obtained, what are the options open to the government? It can either ignore the APC and go against the “nay-sayers” in it, relying more on its own popularity than on an all-parties support, or call off the operation. Will the APC be any help on Monday?
Read more
Labels: APC, Militants, Pakistan, Pakistan Army Operation, Swat, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 11:52 AM,
,
![]()
