Pakistan in Media

Opinionated Media Coverage

Eunuchs to collect taxes!

Bookmark and Share

Rare it is for the Supreme Court of the nation to bring a hint of a smile to our faces, but the suggestion that eunuchs be appointed as collectors of taxes and of loans from defaulters is worthy of our consideration. The court has advised that the government devise a strategy which would enable the eunuch community to earn an honest living rather than engaging in begging or prostitution or dancing at weddings. It would appear that in parts of India this strategy is employed with some success, and there is no reason to believe that we could not match India’s achievements in this respect. The court heard that the social welfare and health departments of Sindh were already involving the eunuch community in the polio vaccination programme and it would be but a small step to see them engaged in loan and debt recovery.

Unsurprisingly the eunuch community has greeted the court’s suggestion with some delight. They would seek to replicate the model used in India, where eunuchs are paid a percentage, 4 per cent, of whatever is recovered. The eunuch group is given the address of the defaulter or debtor and then proceeds to sing, dance and bang drums outside his house until he pays up. Bona-fide tax collectors accompany the eunuchs to ensure that fiscal proprieties are strictly observed and that the exchequer benefits appropriately. Such is the fear of the eunuchs that they are finding considerable success in this new line of work. Our own eunuchs may be attracted by the thought of the sums they may be helping to recover – and 4 per cent of a billion rupees is enough to guarantee some much-extended singing, dancing and general raising of an embarrassing ruckus. Levity aside, this is an eminently sensible and humane suggestion coming down from the legal heights and we see no reason why this marginalised community should be denied an opportunity to turn their skills to good and profitable purpose. It may stretch credulity to imagine that they would be employed to recover defaulted loans valued in billions of rupees, but there are other more modest sums which could be pried from the pockets of defaulters. There is no reason either why they should not deploy their charms in an attempt to net some of the bigger fish – as no man is completely above embarrassment.
source

Labels: ,

posted @ 11:22 AM, ,

Missing persons case

Bookmark and Share

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court on Monday directed the Interior Ministry to submit before the court details pertaining to Pakistani citizens who have been handed over to foreign countries.

A three-member bench of the apex court headed by Justice Javed Iqbal, hearing the case of missing persons, observed that it will not give more time to the government for tracing the whereabouts of the missing people.
more

Labels: , ,

posted @ 7:41 AM, ,

Council of Churches raises issue of blasphemy law

Bookmark and Share

The World Council of Churches, which speaks on behalf of churches in 110 countries, has raised the issue of the blasphemy law in Pakistan. It is concerned that all minorities in Pakistan live in fear of persecution, discrimination, murder and, above all, prosecution on trumped-up charges of blasphemy under the 1986 blasphemy laws. The WCC has called on our legislators to change the law which among other things prescribes the death penalty for blaspheming Islam. This piece of legislation has been used time and time again to harass and intimidate members of the minorities – and cases where Muslims have been prosecuted for blaspheming against other faiths, defiling their holy books or desecrating their places of worship appear nowhere in the legal record. The blasphemy laws, it seems, work only in one direction.

Intolerance is spreading wide and deep across our society. There is no sign of the so-called 'moderate majority' either finding a voice or the political strength and influence to counter it, and we sleepwalk towards a time when extremism is the underpinning of the normative values that shape our lives. Politicians are fond of invoking this invisible 'moderate majority' from time to time, and there is an assumption which appears entirely without foundation that this group actually exists within our society. There is certainly a moderate minority, and we see and hear them in the media daily but we should not extrapolate from that a presumption that they are in any way representative. The extremists have a hand on the media as well, and have little difficulty in speaking to their constituency – one which is far more easily mobilized, has political clout and any number of mouthpieces. The WCC call for changes to the blasphemy laws will be heard by the moderate minority and ignored by everybody else; the minorities will continue to live in fear and extremism will once again have tightened its grip on the national throat.
source

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 6:58 AM, ,

Rights of Minorities

Bookmark and Share

A GROUP of Muslims, professedly incensed and enraged over the alleged desecration of the Quran, killed seven Christians in Gojra in Punjab. The allegation may not have been valid.

It is possible that the victims and their killers had been involved in a local quarrel. It is also possible that the victims were targeted simply because they were non-Muslim. The following presentation is based on this latter premise.
more

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 11:30 AM, ,

Discriminatory legislation

Bookmark and Share

There remains an urgent yet unaddressed need for state policies to reflect the country’s diversity. Regulating madrassas, reforming the public education sector, and invoking constitutional restrictions against private armies and hate speech are essential steps to stem the tide of religious extremism

As if the militancy currently gripping the country were not enough, a mob in a remote village of Toba Tek Singh, angered by the alleged desecration of the Quran, torched 40 houses and a church, where seven people, including two children and an elderly man, were burnt to death.
more

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 8:33 PM, ,

Are we all responsible for Gojra?

Bookmark and Share

The perpetrators were not just a few masked fanatics but a large crowd of ordinary people. Indeed they represented the average Pakistani. Sadly that is what we have become. And that is the real existential crisis that confronts us as a nation at this time

Just a few months ago, almost everybody was declaring that the Taliban posed an ‘existential’ threat to Pakistan. The recent massacre of Christians in Gojra has proven clearly that the real existential threat to Pakistan is and always was from the fanatics within.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 11:35 AM, ,

Religious persecution

Bookmark and Share

The issue of religious persecution is certainly one of morality and justice. But at the end of the day it also has to do with our survival and prosperity as a nation. Whatever the basis, if a large number of citizens begin to feel vulnerable and persecuted it is not too difficult to imagine the eventual outcome

In the wake of atrocities against the Christian community in Gojra, Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani has announced that the government may review the country’s blasphemy laws and that a committee will soon be constituted for this purpose. This is encouraging but committees are also a way of cold-storaging issues so we will have to see if the laws introduced by a military dictator, who relentlessly invoked Islam for the purpose of prolonging his own rule, will finally be amended.
more

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 12:01 PM, ,

Change the controversial blasphemy law

Bookmark and Share

The prime minister, during a visit to Gojra, has indicated the government could seek to change the controversial blasphemy law. While he avoided any direct reference to sections 295 A, B and C of the Pakistan Penal Code, which deal with blasphemy, he said ‘discriminatory’ laws would be reviewed. Although a minor amendment in the blasphemy laws, laying down investigation at a higher police level before pressing charges, was brought in under Musharraf, more sweeping amendments were put aside after an outcry by clerics. This time there is a need to act with wisdom and good sense. The attack on the homes of Christians in Gojra has been widely condemned. There seems no reason to believe that saner religious elements at least would protest changes required to prevent such happenings in the future. They need to be brought aboard now, so that the demands by extremist forces can be countered. The Islamic Ideology Council can also play a role. This under-utilized body has made a number of incredibly sensible proposals in past years. It is a failure of governance that has resulted in many of these suggestions remaining relegated to files.
more

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 11:57 AM, ,

Persecution in the name of religion

Bookmark and Share

THIS month we will be commemorating for the 62nd year running the carnage which engulfed the subcontinent in the name of religion — violence in the name of religion refuses to dissipate.

Yet again the land of five rivers has witnessed a spate of communal violence in which seven people were burnt alive, and much property and scores of houses ravaged. After 62 years the perpetrators and the victims have changed, but the motives and background remain the same.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 2:40 PM, ,

Persecution of Christians in Gojra

Bookmark and Share

Dawn, Pakistan, Tuesday, 04 Aug, 2009
THE frenzied mob that hit a Christian settlement near Gojra on two consecutive days last week proves how easy it is to lose all sense of reason. Masked young men, egged on by religious leaders and actively supported by locals angry over the alleged desecration of the Holy Quran by some members of the Christian community, performed a veritable dance of death in the neighbourhood. They torched houses, smashed businesses and brought routine life to a screeching halt through their seemingly unstoppable violence — until seven Christians were burnt alive and the Rangers called in. On both days the entire area around the targeted settlement was the site of arson, interspersed with stone-throwing, baton-wielding and gunfire.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 10:46 AM, ,

Mistreatment of Christians in Gojra, T.T. Singh

Bookmark and Share

Daily Times, Pakistan, Monday, August 03, 2009
After a week of simmering Muslim-Christian dispute over the alleged desecration of the Holy Quran in tehsil Gojra in Toba Tek Singh district in Punjab, violence has broken out simply because the local administration ignored orders from Lahore to control the situation. The Punjab Chief Minister, Shahbaz Sharif, has suspended the persons responsible for letting this very familiar type of incident get out of hand. Seven Christians have been burnt alive and their houses torched. There may be more casualties.
More

Labels: , ,

posted @ 9:01 AM, ,

Recent Persecution of Christians

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan, Monday, August 03, 2009
No member of any religious or ethnic minority anywhere in the country will be feeling safe and secure today. Members of the Christian minority will be feeling particularly threatened as the details of the events at Gojra on Friday and Saturday last emerge. Seven people, possibly more, have been burned alive in their houses. As of Sunday afternoon the number of injured has risen to over 70. Almost a hundred houses have been damaged in the Christian colony. TV channels showed live pictures of wanton destruction and of a police force that beyond lobbing a few tear-gas shells at nobody in particular, was interested only in containing and not quelling the riot. The disturbances broke out after several religious parties held a public meeting to protest against an alleged desecration of the Holy Quran. Local Christians were said to be the desecrators and as has now become the norm their property was attacked, their churches desecrated, their lives and livelihoods destroyed. Unusually, the Christians fought back, and there was an exchange of fire between the attackers and their intended victims; perhaps an indication that a community which is generally peaceable and unarmed is arming itself for protection. The attack was led by masked men said to be members of a banned religious organisation who had reportedly entered the town from nearby Jhang. The violence had subsided by Sunday morning and an uneasy calm prevailed with Rangers holding the perimeter.
More

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 8:57 AM, ,

Sex Workers

Bookmark and Share

Dawn, Pakistan, Sunday, 12 Jul, 2009
ILLEGAL though their trade may be, it must be recognised that sex workers often pay with their lives to earn a livelihood. Last week’s efforts to address the health hazards of their occupation may have taken a long time coming, but must be lauded as a significant step. The United Nations Population Fund reportedly set up a three-day training session for sex workers with the collaboration of the National Aids Control Programme to generate sexual health awareness in the community through ‘skill building and implementation of strategies’. Disturbing figures thrown up by surveys in 2007 revealed that an alarming 80 per cent of these workers have either been abused or suffer from disease. The reasons remain age-old: illiteracy, biological constitution, male domination, poor hygienic conditions in red-light localities, negligible health facilities, and most importantly, the absence of a say in safe-sex practices.
More

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 1:22 PM, ,

Quota for the disabled

Bookmark and Share

Dawn, Pakistan, Thursday, 09 Jul, 2009
IN a country where employment and economic opportunities are a struggle for most people, the plight of disabled people is often neglected. These citizens face discrimination from society at large, where the lack education combined with low levels of awareness about disabilities leads to the handicapped being viewed with anything from derision to fear. Meanwhile, the support offered by the state and its institutions is minimal. Consider that the chief justice of the Lahore High Court recently took suo motu notice of the fact that disabled people were not being appointed to posts in federal and provincial government departments, although a two per cent job quota had been fixed from them. Subsequently, the deputy attorney general informed the court that 800 vacancies in various departments would be filled “soon” against the quota for the disabled, while just over 1,300 people had already been appointed. Meanwhile, the Punjab Social Welfare director stated that committees had been formed for the recruitment of disabled people in 31 districts of the province, and that such committees would soon be formed in the remaining districts.
More

Labels: ,

posted @ 9:44 AM, ,

Empty pockets

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Monday, June 22, 2009
A press release issued by the NWFP information department says that the number of people displaced by the fighting in Swat and elsewhere has now reached 3.8 million. About 150 thousand are in camps and the rest – by far the majority – are living with relatives or in makeshift accommodation. The operation currently under way in Bannu is producing its own crop of IDPs and if the military moves on Waziristan then we may expect another half-million to gravitate towards Peshawar and the area immediately surrounding it. Describing this as a human catastrophe does no justice to the scale of the problem faced by the government, provincial and federal, and the national and international agencies that are struggling to provide relief services. Overwhelmed by the magnitude of the disaster, aid agencies now face what is being described as the worst funding-shortfall for any major disaster in the last ten years. Simply, they are running out of money and unless their pockets are refilled soon they are going to grind to a halt.
More

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 11:43 AM, ,

Child-trafficking train missing on tracks!

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan, Saturday, June 20, 2009
LAHORE: The Punjab Police and railway authorities launched a search of trains on Friday night after a boy claimed he had jumped from a moving goods train near Sama Satta while being smuggled to some unknown city along with dozens of other boys.

The nine-year-old boy, later identified as Noshad, said he jumped from a moving goods train at Kalanch Wala near Samma Satta railway station, according to the area police. Police sources say that if they believe the boyís story, a big human smuggling network might be at work in the country in connivance with the railway officials.
More

Labels: , ,

posted @ 9:12 AM, ,

Supreme Court orders survey of eunuchs across country

Bookmark and Share

Daily Times, Wednesday, June 17, 2009

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court (SC) on Tuesday directed social welfare secretaries of all four provinces to conduct a survey for documenting the record of eunuchs across the country.
Read More

Labels: ,

posted @ 10:44 AM, ,

The 'grey' prisoner

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
The FIA has approached America's FBI to be permitted access to Dr Aafia Siddiqui, on the basis that she is a Pakistani citizen and that questioning her could help unravel some of the mysteries of terrorism in the country. Certainly, the case of Dr Siddiqui remains just as covered in mist as it was in 2008, when she was traced after a UK journalist claimed she had been held at Bagram Jail. There are still no clear answers as to how she got here, after being taken away from Karachi in 2003. Her son, Ahmed, has described how he was blindfolded and chained by US officials while being shifted from one place to another. The boy, not yet a teenager at the time, also says he attended school for barely a month through these years.
Read More

Labels: , ,

posted @ 10:28 AM, ,

Victim of acid attack

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, Dawn, Pakistan
Saturday, 30 May, 2009

THE recent acid attack in Jhang that permanently blinded the victim is illustrative of how poor police performance and the influence of the feudal elite combine to perpetuate a backward social set-up where the extremes of brutality go unpunished. The victim, Halima, was reportedly attacked by a disappointed suitor and his father. The young woman’s father claims that he was earlier set upon and injured by the same men. Although a case had been registered, the police did not arrest the assailants who apparently have connections with an MPA. Halima was subsequently attacked in her own home. A second case was registered. While the police arrested two of the nominated accused this time, the men were later released, reportedly upon the MPA’s intervention. The crime reflects an intensely retrogressive social set-up where even the smallest act of defiance can invite dire penalties. It also underscores the extent to which women in a backward patriarchal system are denied their most fundamental rights and targeted as prime victims. By default the same system condones a male mindset which hardly recognises crimes against women as punishable. Acid attacks are not uncommon after all. Neither are practices such as karo-kari, vani and swara, all of which are regularly reported from Sindh, southern Punjab and other areas.

Moreover, as the victim’s father legitimately pointed out, had the police taken action on his earlier complaint the attack on his daughter may have been prevented. Evidence of the police’s failure to perform their duty lies in that the FIR for the acid attack reportedly omitted invoking certain relevant sections of the law. This worked to the advantage of the accused party. The incident exposes the bias of the police and the manner in which the politically well connected can expect to get away with practically any crime. The rule of law invoked by political parties must be applied in its real sense. It must be ensured that lawbreakers are punished according to the gravity of their crime. Until the police and justice system are cleansed of political influence, the rights of people such as Halima will continue to be violated with impunity.
Source

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 11:26 AM, ,

Sea of misery

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, The News International, Pakistan
Monday, May 25, 2009
The UN has launched an appeal for $543m to help the over 1.5 million people displaced in Pakistan. The UN has described the scale of the displacement as overwhelming. The head of its office for humanitarian coordination had previously described the crisis as one of the worst ever. Accounts of the suffering of the IDPs continue to pour in. High heat, sickness and a lack of facilities at camps all add to these. The situation is an exceedingly complicated one to tackle. Rarely have so many people streamed out of homes so rapidly and in so much distress. The limited capacity of the state to cope with disaster has aggravated the situation. To make matters worse, more displacements could follow, from Waziristan and other areas where the military operation may soon be extended. We see before us a sea of misery with no signs yet of the shore anywhere in sight. Experienced relief agencies which have worked before in all kinds of condition of crisis admit to being overwhelmed and at a loss to tackle the situation. Efforts are being made also to reach out to IDPs based with host families, but there are as yet many difficulties inherent in this.

While global attention is at least focused on the IDP issue, the situation of people still based in the conflict zone is being largely forgotten. According to information that has emerged from Kalam, where local people have agreed to an uneasy truce with the local Taliban, there are desperate shortages of food and medicine. Women are said to have died in childbirth because there was no access to medical help. Transport has vanished off roads and supply lines have been cut off. There is a need for this situation too to be addressed. The humanitarian crisis needs to be taken note of as a whole. The Pakistan government needs to consider requesting the Red Cross and other groups with expertise in war zones to move into areas of fighting. People there too need assistance as do the millions who have fled. Aid drives to collect funds are now on across the country – but there is still a need to do much more to offer succour to people who face a nightmarish reality in which they have been driven from homes and forced into an inhospitable situation.

Source

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 9:48 AM, ,


Enter your email address: