Pakistan in Media

Opinionated Media Coverage

Swat revived

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, June 09, 2009

Indicators outside of the major state and international actors are the people of Swat, who are themselves looking to a time in the not-far future when they will return to their land and homes. And businesses. And farms. Already there are reports of residents discussing how to revive the tourism industry in Kalam, and an understanding that foreign tourists may be a couple of years hence, but domestic tourism should be up and running again next season. Tourism may be the easier nut to crack – putting farms back on their feet and replacing lost livestock will be much harder. Local strains of cattle, sheep and goats cannot be replaced easily; land which has been fought over and perhaps mined – and is anyway bound to contain unexploded munitions that present a danger to agricultural activity – will take more than a season to get back into profit. Difficult it may be but not impossible, and the deep well of social capital within of Swati communities will help to sustain the process of post-war regeneration. But social capital is not measured in hard cash – and hard cash they need. Swat presented an overarching threat – it could again – but it may also be an unparalleled opportunity for the government and the people to remake the social contract.

Read More

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 9:40 AM, ,

The journey home (of IDPs)

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Monday, June 08, 2009

The meeting between top leaders of the NWFP government and the military to discuss a roadmap for the return of the IDPs to their homes once the military operation is over is significant. Cooperation between the civil and military setup is vital in the post-conflict phase. The mutual mistrust between the two has often hampered matters in the past and this is one of the fundamental factors behind the many administrative and even political failures that we have had to suffer. The military, for its part, has frequently been too quick to dismiss politicians as inept or unwilling. Frequently the politicians too have failed to work in coordination with the military. The situation in Swat and other zones of fighting is now such that they must do so.

Read More

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 9:36 AM, ,

Pakistan Says Tide Has Turned in Swat; Refugees Not So Sure

Bookmark and Share

By Karen DeYoung
Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, June 5, 2009

SWABI, Pakistan, June 4 -- Pakistan's army chief, Gen. Ashfaq Kiyani, declared Thursday that the tide had "decisively turned" in the military's battle against Taliban extremists in the Swat Valley, but displaced Pakistanis in a sprawling tent city here said it was still unsafe for them to return home.

Read More

Labels: , , , , , , ,

posted @ 8:10 PM, ,

Next phase in Buner?

Bookmark and Share

Dawn, Pakistan
Tuesday, 02 Jun, 2009

AS more villages, towns and cities in Malakand division are cleared and held by the security forces, the NWFP and federal governments are gearing up for IDPs to return to their homes in some areas and begin to piece together their lives. Interior Minister Rehman Malik has said that 90 per cent of Buner has now been cleared of militants and told the IDPs from the area that it is safe to return home. Crucially, NWFP Information Minister Iftikhar Hussain announced on Sunday, “The leave of NWFP government’s employees except teachers in Buner district has been cancelled and they have been directed to report for duty [from June 1].” Additionally, staff handling the local electricity, telephone and gas networks and officers of the town municipal authorities have also been asked to return to duty. What this means then is that the local administration in Buner, as has already been promised in Mingora, Swat, is to be reactivated quickly and the area made habitable for the local population once again. If the plan is carried out as efficiently as possible, it will undoubtedly be a tremendous boost to the beleaguered people of Buner — and would offer hope to the IDPs from other areas that the state will help them resettle in their homes in due time.

Perhaps most critical to the resettlement phase is the revival of the local police forces. A primary target of the militants, the police have been decimated and demoralised. Yet, security at the local level can best be ensured by a police force with sufficient numbers and resources. From this point of view, it is welcome to see that the police force in Buner has returned to conduct joint operations with the army. Given the knowledge that a local police officer would have of neighbourhoods and the local population, the police are a vital cog in the house-to-house searches that are necessary to flush out the remaining militants trying to hide among the population. And from the perspective of sending a positive signal to a frightened population that normality is being restored, the sight of local police officers patrolling neighbourhoods is infinitely more reassuring than soldiers armed to the teeth and brought in from outside areas.

Elsewhere, it is reassuring to see the federal government has not taken its eye off the ball and is trying to keep its focus on the operation in Malakand division. President Zardari chaired a meeting of top political, administrative and security officials on Monday, indicating that the government at least understands the need for the various arms of the state to stay informed about each others’ actions. We have said it before and we’ll say it again: a counter-insurgency can only be successful if the full force of the state — political, administrative and military — is brought to bear against the militants.

Source

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

posted @ 11:02 AM, ,

Go home – or else!

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, June 02, 2009

According to an official announcement made by the interior ministry on Sunday 31st May, all the militants have now been ejected from Buner and it is safe for IDPs to return to their homes – that is, if they have homes to return to. The announcement contains an order to government officers who were employed in the civil administration of Buner to return as well and furthermore to return with all speed – and if they don't then they may suffer unspecified consequences. To say that this directive lacks sensitivity understates the case by several orders of magnitude. Those who fled Buner took only what they were able to carry, and they were totally unprepared for the upheaval of their lives – as were other IDPs. They are now dispersed through a range of camps, government schools and private houses. Some will be registered and others not. Some will have heard the message from the government and others not. Some may be in a position to return to Buner immediately – but it is far more likely that many of them will not be able to make the required response. Who is going to transport them? Are the areas where they lived truly clear of the Taliban and are the army and the paramilitary forces there in sufficient strength to ensure that they can now hold the ground they have taken?

It is said that the Mardan, Rustam, Ambala, Daggar and Sultanwas roads have been cleared and it is safe for IDPs to travel on them. Alternative power supplies have been arranged via generators but there is little news of water supplies or telecommunications. There can be little doubt that the entire infrastructure of Buner – as well as everywhere else that has been and continues to be fought over – has been degraded to a greater or lesser extent. There are reports that the entire centre of Mingora has been razed to the ground for instance, and it is reasonable to assume the civil servants who are being pressed to return are unlikely to find their desks and filing systems in apple-pie order. It is likely that for some at least their offices no longer exist. Chains of command and management will be broken by absent members, and issuing a directive with an implication of penalty for those who fail to comply displays a fundamental lack of understanding of the plight faced by the IDPs. Yes, the civil administration needs to be up and running again as quickly as possible. But issuing veiled threats to people already traumatized by the experience of uprooting themselves and their families is no way to win any hearts and minds – indeed we might imagine that alienation and anger would be an appropriate response to this latest display of ineptitude.

Source

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

posted @ 10:04 AM, ,

Ruins of war

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, June 02, 2009

It seems inappropriate to be celebrating what seems like approaching victory in the battle for Swat. The initial accounts of the scenes in Mingora are horrifying. Corpses are said to lie along streets. There are grotesque stories of stray dogs gnawing them. People report cooking leaves or grass to survive. The injured lie untreated in beds. There are acute shortages of medicine and the International Committee of the Red Cross, after going into Swat, has expressed concern over the situation in hospitals. We do not know if worse may lie ahead as other areas of Swat are freed from the grip of the Taliban. All this of course is the outcome of a war we all wished to avoid but were ultimately forced to go into. However, even in war, there are humanitarian rules that apply. These have been violated in Swat and elsewhere, by both sides engaged in fighting. The rules are aimed essentially at minimizing civilian suffering in war. In contrast the Taliban have attempted to maximize it, holding non-combatants as hostages in one place after the other. The placing of landmines in Mingora is another example of an attempt to inflict harm on innocent women, children and men. But the military too is not entirely blameless. The shortages of food in Mingora had been reported for days. Perhaps a greater effort should have been made to air-drop supplies or make other efforts to prevent starvation.

This of course is easier to say from a distance. The military is engaged in war, even if it is fought within the boundaries of its own country, and its primary target must be to win it. However, given the possibility of further fighting, in Waziristan and elsewhere, some basic parameters are required. The nature of this war and its goal of winning back not just territory but also hearts and minds, means sparing civilian suffering must be a key objective. The scenes we see now in Mingora must be avoided elsewhere. Perhaps we need to think more seriously about mass evacuations of civilian populations. This was proposed by the provincial government at one point. At the very least a better plan is needed to prevent so much misery for so many. This is all the more true given that those left behind in Mingora and other towns are in many cases the most impoverished, who simply cannot leave. They need protection from the state.

The immediate priority must be to rush aid to Mingora and other areas. People there are desperate for help. A plan to offer it, involving international humanitarian groups, the provincial government and local organizations must immediately be put into place. Both in the short and long term there is much to be done. The effort to do so simply cannot be delayed.

Source

Labels: , , , , , , ,

posted @ 9:59 AM, ,

IDPs: the health aspect

Bookmark and Share

By Huma Yusuf
Monday, 01 Jun, 2009

IT is said that bad news comes in threes. In recent months, Pakistan has had to deal with the Taliban consolidating their stranglehold over the Frontier province.

Now, the government is trying to manage one of the largest displacements of a population the world has ever seen as over three million people have left the tribal areas and Malakand division.

What will come next? While many Pakistanis remain preoccupied with the potential breakup of the country and reports of the Taliban’s relocation to Balochistan and Sindh, the next problem we face may well be a health crisis. If immediate action is not taken, Pakistan could be plagued with a polio epidemic.

Along with Afghanistan, India and Nigeria, Pakistan is one of the four countries where polio continues to thrive. Twelve cases have been confirmed across the country this year. This number is expected to rise as Swatis fleeing the military operation in their valley spill across the country. The fact is residents of the Malakand division are extremely vulnerable to a polio outbreak.

Since October 2008, none of the target population — over 377,000 children under the age of five — in Swat has been vaccinated owing to the deteriorating security situation and military offensives. As early as September 2007, threats to health workers disrupted vaccination campaigns in about half the valley. The trouble began when Swat-based extremist cleric Maulana Fazlullah, better known as Maulana Radio, came on air using an illegal FM transmitter to denounce polio vaccination. He argued that polio drops were part of a western conspiracy to render Muslims infertile.

Before Fazlullah’s anti-vaccination campaign gained momentum, a case of polio had not been reported in the valley since 2003. But many in the Frontier province seem to have taken his logic to heart: in January this year, 278 families in Upper Dir, including Dir town, refused to let health workers administer anti-polio medication to their children, describing the drops as un-Islamic. As a result, between January and May this year, five polio cases have been reported from across the Frontier province and part of the tribal areas.

The mass exodus resulting from the ongoing military operation presents opportunities as well as serious challenges in terms of a polio epidemic. First, the good news: as they leave the Malakand division, under-immunised children are finally accessible to health workers to administer polio drops. Camps established for internally displaced persons (IDPs) also gather populations in urgent need of polio vaccination in specific localities.

In the past few weeks, health workers affiliated with the Global Polio Eradication Initiative have established themselves at nine transit points along the routes from Malakand, Swabi and Mardan. They had successfully immunised 17,850 children with trivalent oral polio vaccine by mid-May. Mobile health teams have also gone tent to tent in 26 IDP camps, immunising almost 7,000 children last month. These efforts are baby steps that may help counter the precarious health situation created by Fazlullah’s preposterous rhetoric.

But much more is needed. Even if one child is affected, children across Pakistan remain at risk because polio spreads rapidly in populations that have not been immunised. Health workers are quick to point out that haphazard displacement trends and crowded camps make it impossible to ensure that every child under the age of five receives the vaccine. According to provincial health officials, up to 1.3 million children in the Frontier province are expected to miss vaccination owing to the mass displacement.

Moreover, given the lapse in regular vaccination in recent years, it is possible that undiagnosed children already carrying the wild polio virus are now exposing dozens more to the disease in IDP camps. Since many IDPs have scattered across Pakistan to avail of the hospitality of host families, children throughout the country are now at a higher risk of infection.

In this context, National Immunisation Days become more important than ever. One hopes that the most recent drive, which occurred on May 28-30, was able to reach the 33 million children nationwide that it was targeting. The government should investigate the thoroughness of that drive and launch another initiative if there are fears that many children have not been vaccinated.

Moreover, some of the aid pouring in can be used to establish clear systems to ensure that all children in IDP camps have been immunised. Mobile health teams can also continually man routes with heavy traffic in the coming months to ensure that IDPs — those leaving or returning to Malakand — have received anti-polio medication.

But what about those families who actively prevented their children from receiving polio drops for fear that the medication would corrupt or sterilise them? One wishes there were a vaccine to counter ideological brainwashing. In the absence of one, the government and international community will have to put health on the agenda as part of any ‘winning hearts and minds’ campaign.

Once again, community radio broadcasts (first in IDP camps and subsequently across Fata and the Frontier) featuring correct information about polio vaccination backed by local authorities such as clerics and maliksmight be the best way to forever quash Fazlullah’s nonsensical theories.

In the short term, the threat of a polio outbreak should not be used by officials as an excuse to deny IDPs shelter and support. Rather, provincial governments in Sindh, Punjab and Balochistan should reflect on the health crisis among the IDP population as a way to get in some soul-searching. The only reason potentially polio-carrying IDPs pose a threat in other parts of the country is because recent provincial vaccination efforts have not been comprehensive — and they don’t have the excuse of a perilous security situation.

For example, the latest confirmed case of polio comes from the Multan district of southern Punjab, one of the most populous in the country. In Karachi, meanwhile, 217,000 children (about nine per cent of the target population) were not immunised during campaigns in April 2009. Indeed, polio is on the rise in Sindh — with or without the IDPs (compare five cases in 2005 to 18 cases in 2008). If properly managed by the government, attempts to raise awareness and eradicate polio risk among the IDP population could, in turn, benefit the country as a whole.

It may seem premature to be worrying about a polio epidemic when IDPs barely have access to food, potable water and shelter. But Pakistan has a bad habit of worrying about the benefits of foresight only in hindsight. While making efforts to accommodate the IDPs, the government should simultaneously work towards comprehensive polio vaccination. That way, we may save ourselves another major crisis in the coming years.

huma.yusuf@gmail.com

Source

Labels: , , , , , ,

posted @ 1:56 PM, ,

‘Let them eat cake’

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Monday, June 01, 2009

The French queen Marie Antoinette is famously - and wrongly – said to have uttered the infamous phrase ‘then let them eat cake’ on hearing that the peasantry had no bread to eat; and it was probably said 100 years before her by Marie-Thérèse, the wife of Louis XIV. The phrase has become synonymous with the arrogant attitudes of the ruling classes to those at the bottom of the pile and although we hope that nobody here is so heartless as to actually say it, we do take note of some chronic insensitivities towards the IDPs. In particular we note the fact that Punjab, in making a contribution to the support of IDPs, has donated wheat. Wheat as we all know needs to be ground into flour before it can be made into bread – and giving somebody a sackful of wheat without the wherewithal to grind it is about as much use as presenting them with a chocolate bicycle on midsummer’s day. A consequence of this anomaly is that IDPs are forced to sell the bags of wheat at knock-down prices to the millers in order that they can afford to buy flour to make the bread that will feed them. The millers then grind the wheat which they re-sell at inflated prices to the IDPs, thus recycling back to the millers the money that they used to capitalize what for them is a very lucrative business.

The stock of cake in the godowns of one of the leading aid agencies, UNICEF, is also running low. It has almost exhausted its contingency funds and stocks of relief goods and has appealed for an additional $41.4 million for providing immediate assistance to people displaced by fighting in Swat and elsewhere. UNICEF is providing drinking water, nutrition, health support and education for many of those in the camps and the far greater number accommodated in host communities and extended families. With around three million now displaced and no end to their misery in sight we face a problem of medium-term sustenance rather than emergency relief. The random and often inappropriate donation and distribution of aid helps nobody and often serves to heighten the sense of loss felt by IDPs. Giving wheat to people who need flour is tantamount to saying ‘then let them eat cake’ – which we are sure is not the message that Punjab wanted to give to the IDPs.

Source

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 9:42 AM, ,

The IDP issue

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan
Sunday, May 31, 2009

During a visit to a camp in Swabi on May 29, President Asif Ali Zardari has made it clear he sees the IDPs as people who deserve the attention of the entire nation. The comments come at a time when controversy over the entry of the displaced persons into Sindh continues. In cities of Punjab too, vague allegations that unemployed young men from Swat and elsewhere may be involved in armed crime has led to hesitation on the part of people regarding their attitudes towards the IDPs. The entire situation needs to be looked at rationally and realistically. There is every possibility that some of the IDPs may not be able to return home for several months. Meanwhile there is also a distinct likelihood of further displacements as fighting continues and its arena is expanded to Waziristan and other stretches of the northern areas such as the Kurram Agency.

There can be no doubt at all that the IDPs deserve all possible help and the support of other citizens. The UN has termed the displacements, which the Pakistan government says has brought three million people out of their homes, one of the largest and most rapid in recent times.. Health experts visiting camps have stressed the need for immediate measures to stem the rapid onslaught of disease and to improve the living conditions. Reports say many IDPs continue to live in abject misery, often with host families, and have little awareness about the benefits of registering themselves. Others at Jallozai complain about long delays holding up the registration process. In short, there seems to be little doubt that there is still a great deal that needs to be done. The immediate requirement is for better sanitation at camps and more facilities for people who may be forced to live in their inhospitable environs for months. This alone will help lessen the sense of trauma.

But we need also to think about the question of the relationship between the IDPs and local communities. The generosity of ordinary people in Mardan and elsewhere has been immense. But is it fair to continue to count on it to sustain the IDPs? Beyond relief, we also need to think of providing some kind of income generation or work facilities for those in camps. The need for cash is said to be acute. It is also unrealistic to expect so many people to sit idle week after week without some occupation. Specialized NGOs and micro-credit institutions may be able to assist in this. We need innovative thinking combined with solid implementation. In the absence of this there is a real risk that the IDP issue will become more and more complicated and create a new spectrum of problems. The government then needs to anticipate the problems and work to avert them.

Source

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 10:49 AM, ,

Unwelcome guests

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Nothing is ever simple. With over a million people now spilled out of the war zone in NWFP, most of them ethnic Pashtuns, it was probably inevitable that there was going to be a point at which they encountered anomie. The rich diversity of the peoples of Pakistan has never been forged into a strength, and is eternally exploited by those whose narrow and often nationalistic fervour sees threat at every turn of the road – and, as is currently the case – some of those moving on it. The IDPs now travelling in all directions did not have their current misfortune as a part of their life-plan. Most of them were settled and, until the Taliban came into their lives, reasonably happy – or as happy as may be possible given the constraints of poverty and lack of development in many an area that was, and still is, their home. That they are on the road or in camps or enjoying the hospitality of friends and extended family is not a situation they have themselves sought in any way; and they are entirely the victims of circumstance. As such they are entitled to a good deal of latitude and the support of all of us – and the great Pakistani public, rich and poor, has displayed its innate humanitarian instinct by donating relief goods in significant quantities. By contrast some of our politicians have again shown their true colours and revealed themselves as grubby little xenophobes eager to fan ethnic frictions into flame.

Karachi in particular and Sindh more generally has seen two days of strikes, the destruction of life and property, the loss of trade and business and an all-round disruption of life for everybody – whatever their ethnicity. All this upheaval is by way of protest against the ‘influx’ of IDP’s from Malakand division and NWFP. At the Sindh-Punjab border the provincial administration stopped a number of buses which were bringing displaced people from NWFP and there are reported to be about 4,000 IDP families currently registered with the Sindh provincial government. The protest and strikes have been led by the Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz (JSQM) who were at least in spirit aided and abetted by elements of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) with some behind-curtain support from the PPP. The ANP has rejected the JSQM/MQM calls for strikes saying they are ‘against Pashtuns’ – an interpretation hard to disagree with, and the coalition that governs Sindh is looking decidedly shaky. Punjab has not helped those on the road much either – saying that no IDP camps would be established in the province but that Punjab would happily support the camps set up in NWFP.

The IDPs were en-route as the result of an invitation issued by Sindh Information Minister Shazia Marri after the provincial government gave a clear message that Sindh would welcome them – a welcome not extended by all. As ever the roots of the problem lie in history near and far. Memories of the Afghan refugees who changed the face not just of Karachi but much of Pakistan are fresh. Older memories are of partition and still older of simmering enmities that are centuries-old – and all brought together in the midsummer hothouse of Karachi which is already at boiling-point as a result of loadshedding. It takes very little to ignite this combustible mix, and it is an act of considerable political irresponsibility to make the spark which may do just that. The IDPs are suddenly everybody’s problem – and nobody’s at the same time, other than the government of NWFP that is. Somewhere in the midst of all this there is an identity that transcends ethnicity – these homeless people are Pakistanis, not foreigners. They have a constitutional right to travel and settle freely in their own country. They are displaced because of the actions of their own government in Islamabad. Most of them will want to get back home as fast as they can. Stigmatising and demonising them is no way to treat people whose misfortune is created other than by themselves; and those poison-tongued politicians who serve their own narrow interests need to button their lips. We have problems enough without creating an extra set of feet to shoot ourselves in.
Source

Labels: , , , , , ,

posted @ 9:45 AM, ,

Pakistani Refugee Crisis Poses Peril

Bookmark and Share

Amid Army Offensive, Extremists Are Filling Needs That the Government Can't

By Griff Witte
Washington Post Foreign Service
Monday, May 25, 2009

MARDAN, Pakistan -- Bacha Zab, a 32-year-old fruit salesman, dodged army shelling and Taliban sniper fire to escape his native Swat Valley. But when he reached the safety of a government-run refugee camp in this northwestern Pakistani city, he was told there was no more room.

Instead, for the past 16 days, Zab, his wife and their four children have been in the care of a private Islamic charity with close ties to a banned militant organization. "We are asking for help from the government, but they won't give it," Zab said. "In the government camps, there are only problems."

The government has been overwhelmed by the human tide that has washed over the northwest as about 2 million people have fled fierce clashes in Swat. With Pakistan experiencing its largest exodus since the nation's partition from India in 1947, only a fraction of the displaced civilians are receiving assistance in government-run camps. The rest are fending for themselves or getting help from private charities, including some that are allied with the very forces the Pakistani army is fighting in Swat.

Refugee camps in Pakistan have been prime recruiting grounds for militant groups ever since the Soviet invasion forced millions of Afghans to cross into Pakistan in the 1980s. Now, concern is growing that this latest wave of displacement will create a fresh crop of Pakistanis with grievances against the government and loyalty to groups that seek to undermine the state through violent insurgency.

The government says it is aware of the peril, but it appears incapable of mustering the resources it needs to provide shelter, food, water and medicine to so many people.

"If people are not looked after well, they tend to become extremists. It hasn't happened yet, but we're very conscious of it," said Farhatullah Babar, a spokesman for President Asif Ali Zardari. "It's a big task."

Critics say the government has badly mismanaged the crisis, having failed to prepare for a scenario that officials must have known would result from the military offensive. "They should have foreseen this, but they didn't plan for it," said Aftab Khan Sherpao, an opposition lawmaker and former interior minister who comes from the northwest. "The people are not happy with the militants, but they're not happy with the army and the government, either. Now that anger will build up."

The true dimensions of the refugee problem are apparent in Mardan, one of the primary destinations for civilians fleeing the battles in Swat and in neighboring Buner and Dir. The city is studded with refugee camps consisting of endless rows of tan canvas tents that bake under 110-degree skies. Schools are packed to capacity with families sleeping on concrete classroom floors, with each classroom housing 40 or more people. Local residents say that virtually every spare bedroom in the city is being used to host displaced civilians, who may have to wait months or longer to return home.

Save the Children, an international aid organization that is providing assistance to the displaced families, estimated late last week that more than 80 percent of the people who had fled were living outside the camps, which number about 25. More than half the refugees are children, the group says.

The Pakistani government, already battling economic troubles before it launched its offensive in Swat, is heavily dependent on international aid for its support programs. The United Nations said Friday that it was seeking $543 million in additional donations to help those displaced by the fighting. The United States has announced $110 million in aid, which includes tents, radios and generators.

In the camps, there is seething resentment toward a government that residents say has let them down many times before.

"When we were being forced out of our homes, our president was enjoying himself in the U.S.," said camp resident Syed Karim Shah, referring to a visit by Zardari to Washington just as the battle in Swat got underway. "He's cashing in on this situation, bringing in money from the West."

Shah said the money has yet to filter down to the camps, where residents complain of a lack of bathroom facilities, electricity and fans. The temperatures in Mardan far exceed those in Swat, which is cooled by its relatively high elevation and a glacier-fShah said the money has yet to filter down to the camps, where residents complain of a lack of bathroom facilities, electricity and fans. The temperatures in Mardan far exceed those in Swat, which is cooled by its relatively high elevation and a glacier-fed river that runs through the middle of the valley.

Swat, which was once a major tourist hub and is considered among the most beautiful regions of Pakistan, has long been known for its moderate-minded population. But the Taliban in recent years has capitalized on weak and corrupt governance in the valley, offering locals an alternative form of justice that is swift and severe. The militants have controlled Swat off and on since late 2007. The government's offensive, which was launched nearly a month ago after the collapse of a peace deal and amid intense pressure from the United States, is aimed at retaking the valley once and for all.

But there were fresh signs this weekend that that may not happen soon and that the problem of displacement will worsen. The army launched an operation Saturday aimed at reclaiming the largest city in Swat, Mingora, and warned that the fight will be long and bloody. On Sunday, the army said it had captured key parts of the city -- including an intersection known locally as Slaughterhouse Square because it was used by the Taliban to hang the mutilated bodies of its enemies. Despite the army's gains, much of Mingora remains in Taliban hands, and up to 20,000 civilians are trapped in the city, caught between the military and the militants.

The army has warned that some Taliban fighters joined the fleeing residents and may have infiltrated the refugee camps. Residents of the government camps say that there is little security and that they do not feel safe there.

Outside the camps, groups with radical Islamist agendas are rushing to fill the void left by the paucity of government services. The Falah-e-Insaniat Foundation, the successor to a group known as Jamaat-ud-Dawa, has established a major presence in areas near Swat, feeding tens of thousands of displaced people and providing them with quality medical care.

Jamaat-ud-Dawa was banned late last year on suspicion of involvement in the November attacks in Mumbai that killed more than 170 people. After the ban, however, the group simply passed along its facilities and personnel to Falah-e-Insaniat, which continues to use the same insignia and slogan as the old group: "Free service in the name of Allah."

At the group's centers, which dot the landscape of Mardan, aid is dispensed by burly men with long hair, lengthy beards and firm handshakes.

Mian Adil, the group's deputy chairman in the region, said the organization focuses on serving those who have been unable to get help from the government. He said that if the refugee crisis continues, the group plans to also provide schooling for the children.

Such groups are not the only ones dispensing aid. Moderate Islamic and secular groups have also stepped up to provide a range of services to the displaced.

Just off the main road leading into Mardan, the Initiative for Development and Empowerment Axis, a secular Pakistani aid group, set up a camp late last week. Almost overnight, it was filled with 40 families. Mohammad Amad, the group's executive director, said his workers were serving an additional 1,400 people who had found shelter in homes or schools.

The group has received help from private donors and organizations, which have offered meals, clothes and money. Amad said he had asked the government for help but had received nothing.

Amad said that Pakistan, the United States and other Western countries could use the refugee crisis as an opportunity to change attitudes for the better, but that they will need to move quickly.

"We can win these people over if we give them the proper support," Amad said. "Loyalties are already eroded. They're already unhappy with the government, and they are unhappy with the West. If we're going to change that, this is the time to do it."

Source

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 9:20 AM, ,

Sea of misery

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, The News International, Pakistan
Monday, May 25, 2009
The UN has launched an appeal for $543m to help the over 1.5 million people displaced in Pakistan. The UN has described the scale of the displacement as overwhelming. The head of its office for humanitarian coordination had previously described the crisis as one of the worst ever. Accounts of the suffering of the IDPs continue to pour in. High heat, sickness and a lack of facilities at camps all add to these. The situation is an exceedingly complicated one to tackle. Rarely have so many people streamed out of homes so rapidly and in so much distress. The limited capacity of the state to cope with disaster has aggravated the situation. To make matters worse, more displacements could follow, from Waziristan and other areas where the military operation may soon be extended. We see before us a sea of misery with no signs yet of the shore anywhere in sight. Experienced relief agencies which have worked before in all kinds of condition of crisis admit to being overwhelmed and at a loss to tackle the situation. Efforts are being made also to reach out to IDPs based with host families, but there are as yet many difficulties inherent in this.

While global attention is at least focused on the IDP issue, the situation of people still based in the conflict zone is being largely forgotten. According to information that has emerged from Kalam, where local people have agreed to an uneasy truce with the local Taliban, there are desperate shortages of food and medicine. Women are said to have died in childbirth because there was no access to medical help. Transport has vanished off roads and supply lines have been cut off. There is a need for this situation too to be addressed. The humanitarian crisis needs to be taken note of as a whole. The Pakistan government needs to consider requesting the Red Cross and other groups with expertise in war zones to move into areas of fighting. People there too need assistance as do the millions who have fled. Aid drives to collect funds are now on across the country – but there is still a need to do much more to offer succour to people who face a nightmarish reality in which they have been driven from homes and forced into an inhospitable situation.

Source

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 9:48 AM, ,

IDPs and Sindh

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, Daily Times
Sunday, May 24, 2009

The Mutahidda Qaumi Movement (MQM) says it supports the “Sindh-based” parties against the accommodation of “outsiders” in the province. The reference is to the internally displaced persons (IDPs) fanning out from the Malakand region to all parts of the country. It is expected that the lion’s share of this migration will be taken by Karachi where there are already 4 million Pashtuns, making it the largest Pashtun city in the world. The MQM says the Taliban had entered the settled areas along with the IDPs and had set up their operational points in Karachi and others cities of Sindh “for suicide attacks and other terrorist activities”.

The MQM has found resonance with Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz (JSQM), which in principle protests injections of alien population in the province till the Sindhi is threatened with becoming a minority in his own province. The Pakistan People’s Party-Shaheed Bhutto (PPP-SB) and JSQM have both urged the government to resettle the IDPs near the affected areas rather than in far-flung localities. The Sindh National Party (SNP) has also taken out a protest march asking Chief Minister Qaim Ali Shah to convene an emergency session of the Sindh Assembly and stop the influx of refugees into Sindh. Ominously, the police go on reporting new arrival of criminals from the tribal areas at the same time, catching some of them as if in proof.

All migrations are accompanied by violence, the only exception in history being that of the Holy Prophet PBUH which actually led to the sanctification of the act of hijra because of its peaceful aftermath. Our Constitution gives the right to all Pakistani citizens to settle wherever they want, but the migration-violence sequence cannot be ignored. The MQM is opposed by the Sindhi nationalist parties, but such is the politics of migration, that it now joins them in opposing it. The Pashtun diaspora swells, made bitter by its terrorist fringe. But the innocent Swatis have to be sheltered till they can return to their paradise. For that, Sindh must prepare itself with the help of the world.

Source

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

posted @ 10:24 AM, ,

Pakistan appeals to US public for aid

Bookmark and Share

21 hours ago

WASHINGTON (AFP) — Pakistan on Friday appealed to the US public to make small donations through their cellphones to help care for some 1.7 million people displaced in a major campaign against Islamic extremists.

Ambassador Hussain Haqqani called on Americans to donate five dollars each by sending text messages and voiced hope that television networks would encourage the effort.

The funds are to provide food, clothing, medicine and other relief goods channeled through the United Nations, which earlier Friday called on the world to contribute a total of 543 million dollars.

"Every American can contribute this small amount and help the displaced people," said Nadeem Kiani, press attache at the embassy.

UN chief Ban Ki-moon urged the international community to take part.

"The Secretary-General urges the international community to show their solidarity with the people of Pakistan by supporting the Humanitarian Response Plan launched today in Islamabad, and the Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Plan presented yesterday by the Government of Pakistan," his spokesperson said in New York.

Ban "is concerned that Pakistan is currently witnessing rapid displacement on a massive scale ... (and) stresses the urgency of raising the 544 million dollars requested in the appeal to address the critical needs of the affected population and assist in the normalization of their lives," she added.

Pakistan says more than 1,050 militants and 58 soldiers have been killed in the offensive, which followed US criticism accusing Islamabad of a weak response to Islamic extremists.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on Tuesday announced 110 million dollars in emergency aid to Pakistan and said that she and State Department employees had already made the text-message donations.

US cellular users can make five-dollar donations by texting "Swat" to the number 20222

Source

Labels: , , , , , , ,

posted @ 10:06 AM, ,

Rejection of IDPs

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, Dawn, Pakistan
Saturday, 23 May, 2009

AS thousands of people continue to flee the battle zones of Malakand division, apprehensions have been expressed by some about the resettlement of IDPs in other parts of the country. This underscores the intensifying tragedy of the IDPs, who are caught between a rock and a hard place with little hope of rescue by either the state or society. The over two million evacuees are not cross-border refugees but people displaced internally as a result of the Taliban-led insurgency and the military response. Indeed, the exodus began in earnest only after residents were told to evacuate in anticipation of the military offensive. Given that this call went out from the government, it was incumbent upon the state to plan for an eventuality of the sort and divert resources towards the protection and rehabilitation of IDPs. Lessons could have been extrapolated from the relief effort in the wake of the 2005 Kashmir earthquake, and bodies such as the National Crisis Management Cell put on standby.

It must also be noted that the insurgency and the need for a military response did not materialise unexpectedly. The interlinked issues of the Taliban and militancy had been festering even before the current government took charge. The matter was repeatedly mishandled by both the state and the army: where the former resorted to ill-advised concessions such as the Nizam-i-Adl Regulation, the latter failed to take decisive action in its earlier attempts to secure the area and, indeed, allowed the operations of persons such as Maulana Fazlullah to continue unchecked until matters reached a crisis point.

Meanwhile, other than in areas close to the conflict zone such as Mardan which received the first flood of evacuees, the response of the citizenry has been sluggish. In Karachi and Hyderabad, the issue has been clouded by ethnicity-based politics, while a glaring lack of empathy is evident in much of the country. This is a factor that could further alienate the IDPs, and prove disastrous in the long term. It is imperative that the IDP crisis not only be understood in its full perspective but that the affectees’ rehabilitation and return to their hometowns become the country’s foremost priority.

Source

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 10:52 AM, ,

Starvation stalks Swat valley

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, Dawn, Pakistan
By Faizullah Jan and Syed Irfan Ashraf
Saturday, 23 May, 2009

POLITICIANS and analysts are often heard discussing the measures being taken to minimise the collateral damage resulting from the Swat and Buner operations.

But their words come across as mere rhetoric to those who are actually experiencing a living hell. While the IDPs in camps have their own set of difficulties where the provision of necessities is involved, those who are still in the Swat valley are facing dire food shortages, a prolonged curfew and Taliban militancy. A phone call from the trapped people in the scenic town of Bahrain on the main Kalam-Mingora road indicates the measure of desperation. “We have been under curfew for the last three weeks. There is no wheat flour, no rice, no sugar, no medicine,” says Iqbal Khan. “Today we eat only peas and potatoes. Soon we will be foraging for leaves in the woods.”

Starvation also stalks the vales of Matta, Odegram, Hazara, Shill Hund, Shah Dheri and Kalam where, as in Bahrain, stocks of food and medicine are fast depleting. Thanks to the curfew, these areas have been cut off from the rest of the country ever since the military operation began. Worried about the looming starvation, a Kalam local, Noor Zada, says over the phone, “We are fighting on two fronts. The Taliban are about to take us to task for defying them while the absence of food and medicine can only kill us.”

While correct figures are not available, it is estimated that over 400,000 people are trapped in the northern belt of Swat stretching from Mingora, Miandam, Madyan and Bahrain to Kalam tehsil. At least 800,000 are believed to be stranded in Kabal, Aligrama, Hazara, Shah Dheri, Shill Hund etc. The plight of thousands living in the main town of Mingora and its outskirts is scarcely any different. While many are unwilling to leave because they are unsure of conditions in camps and the security of their families en route, some have chosen to stay back for other reasons.

In an essentially agrarian society like Swat, families cannot afford to abandon their hearths and homes. Their chattel, standing crops and orchards are their lifeline and looked upon as extensions of their body and soul. The poor farmers of upper Swat invest a whole season of their lives to plough fields and prune orchard trees.

When they lost tourism to the medieval mentality of the jihadists, potatoes and turnips were their only source of sustenance and revenue. They sold their yields down-country to make ends meet, also storing some of the produce for their own use in the harsh winters. But protracted hostilities in the valley have left them with no cash, and supplies in storage are virtually exhausted. Thus starvation awaits the population of Swat if the military operation does not rectify matters. The situation in lower Swat, including the outskirts of Mingora and Bari Kot, is equally alarming.

Operation Rah-i-Rast caught Swat residents unawares. They had little time to pack up and leave for a safer place. Only half the population of Swat managed to leave the valley of death. Even then, a majority left behind one or two family members to guard homes and keep an eye on standing crops and chattel. Others, including scores of families in upper Swat, could not flee due to non-availability of transport or simply because they could not afford the travel expenses. Children are missing in hundreds while families in Peshawar wait for male members to turn up, expecting them to have taken refuge with their relatives in upper Swat — although nothing is certain.

The stranded people face a bizarre situation: death is staring them in the face from three directions. If the military operation is a protracted one, they face starvation because of curfew and the consequent closure of supply routes; if the operation intensifies there is bound to be great collateral damage; and if the Taliban face defeat they may turn on the residents for not being on their side. Their fears are justified.

In November 2007, 60 militants with heavy weapons marched on Kalam tehsil in Swat. However, they left when a local jirga told them to implement Sharia in lower Swat first and then extend it to Kalam. Many Taliban took this as defiance. After two years, over 50 Taliban armed with sophisticated weapons reached Kalam to settle past scores. This led to a clash in which six Taliban were taken hostage. The issue was resolved on Thursday, when the elders of Kalam, fearing a Buner-like situation in which suicide bombings and brutal punishments were imposed on the people for defying the Taliban, offered to free the captured militants in return for the release of 150 of their own people in Taliban custody.

Meanwhile, hospitals in these areas are not functioning. There is no electricity, no medicine, no doctors. Collateral damage does not simply mean death by a stray mortar shell and carpet bombing — it can also include fatalities caused by starvation and disease. This is what analysts and strategists are not factoring into their discussion about civilian casualties in Swat.

With many Swat residents wanting to move out of the area, they need to be supported by the government. The first thing that the government can do is to provide them safe passage — in Kurram Agency people were airlifted although there could be technical difficulties in doing so where Swat’s larger population is concerned — before they end up as the Taliban’s human shields. But before that food and medicine must be airdropped, especially in areas where the militants have not reached.

Today the people of Swat loathe the Taliban and look towards the government to rescue them. They are ready to fight alongside the army against the extremists. But if the government’s apathy and the people’s agony persist — as exemplified at the time of writing by a procession from Bahrain marching towards Madyan chanting ‘atta do ya raasta do’ (‘give us bread or safe passage’) we can end up counting Swat residents among the Taliban.

Source

Labels: , , , , , ,

posted @ 10:42 AM, ,

Human distress

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan

Thursday, May 21, 2009
The UN has described Pakistan's humanitarian crisis as massive, possibly one of the biggest in the world. An agency accustomed to all kinds of human distress seems genuinely over-whelmed. The nature of the crisis is in many ways unique. Within days, over two million people have had to leave homes, often only with the clothes on their backs. They have been displaced into a hostile situation, with high heat, poor sanitation and sickness at camps adding to the misery of those already traumatized by conflict. Many homes have been destroyed, standing crops devastated. In a bid to save them and escape the inhospitable climatic environs of Mardan and Swabi, a few hundred families have been attempting to venture back. To add to the complications, only about 15 percent of the IDPs are based at camps. The remainder are scattered in many locations, often with host families who themselves struggle to cater to their needs. The world now seems to be waking up to the scale of the crisis. The US has pledged $110 million for the displaced and made an eloquent appeal for more donations. The cash-strapped UN agencies are doing what they can; so too are many local groups. But the reality is that the mass displacement represents a kind of nightmare. The situation, like the one that immediately followed the 2005 earthquake, is almost impossible to deal with. There are far too many people involved, far too few facilities.

But the Pakistan government must remember that it is us who will live with the consequences of events currently unfolding within our country. We can only meet disaster by losing sight of this reality. The government, therefore, must take a primary role in deciding what is to be done and how the awful misery of the displaced can at least be eased if not eliminated. We need to think along innovative lines: the possibility of moving camps up to cooler climatic zones, possibly in the Murree area, should be considered. Urgent needs, such as that for safe drinking water must too be identified and made a priority. This step alone could help combat disease such as the outbreak of diarrhoea reported from Jalozai.

Other measures too are needed. One is the question of law and order at the camps. There have been reports of gangs involved in robbery or extortion operating at some of them. Surely it is not beyond our capabilities to police these settlements better. The fact that the IDPs live in fear of criminals is unacceptable. They fear too that the Taliban who many believe will linger on in their areas. Confidence needs to be built on this point too. Other accounts speak of NADRA teams seeking Rs50 to look up details of their record for IDPs, who while fleeing aerial shelling and bullets neglected to bring their NICs with them. This is absurd. NADRA can do without the money and displaced persons need to be rescued from the added burdens of this kind placed on them as a consequence of a decision taken in some air-conditioned office. Schemes to support 'host' families too need to be implemented.

The task is a gigantic one and expands beyond the camps. Scenes of widespread devastation have greeted IDPs who have returned to Buner and parts of Swat. These people will need help to re-build lives. Pakistan must persuade the world and its own people to help deliver this. It must also step up its own efforts and do what it possibly can. Otherwise IDPs who are today helpless victims will return home with anger in their hearts. We must remember similar frustrations have contributed to the rise of the Taliban. This reality alone should be enough to compel us to gear up aid efforts.

Resource

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 10:15 AM, ,

Pakistan refugees blocked from homes by fighting

Bookmark and Share

By KATHY GANNON – 1 day ago

AMBELA, Pakistan (AP) — Waiting at a checkpoint Tuesday under the searing sun, Amina rocked her baby, wrapped in a heavy black burqa. "You'll be home soon," she whispered. But the thud of exploding shells deadened her hopes — and raised questions about military claims the area was clear of Taliban militants.

"What is this government doing? They are telling us to return. Listen to that fighting," said Wasim Khan, who was among the hundreds of refugees waiting to return to their homes in Buner, a district seized by Taliban fighters last month.

A strategic piece of territory, Buner provides the most direct link to the rest of Pakistan from the Taliban-dominated Swat Valley.

Despite army assertions that soldiers have cleared the district of Taliban forces, more troops and heavy artillery poured into the area on Monday, according to Ghulam Bacha, a policeman who suggested the Taliban were dug in deeper than the military originally suspected.

The Taliban overran Buner after a peace deal soured last month, streaming down from their Swat Valley strongholds to within 60 miles of the Pakistani capital, Islamabad, and triggering alarm in the United States.

An army offensive to oust the Taliban has so far caused 1.5 million people to flee. The military claims to have killed about 1,000 Taliban fighters, a figure that cannot be independently verified, and says 50 soldiers have also died in the 3-week-old operation.

Amina and Khan were among some 500 people seeking to return to their villages in Buner Tuesday after the provincial government urged residents to come back, saying the area was safe and the Taliban had been routed.

They waited for hours in a mile-long line of battered trucks piled high with bedding, bundles of clothing and ancient-looking threshing equipment. Whole families perched atop the vehicles' roofs, baking in the sun: women hidden behind burqas, crying children and scores of bearded men.

But they made it only as far as Ambela, a village at the foot of Bela Pass, a winding five-mile-long road that links Buner to the rest of Pakistan.

The refugees were expecting authorities to open the road deeper into Buner, but the shelling put an end to that. A couple of vehicles tried to inch up to the barbed-wire checkpoint blocking the narrow pass, but soldiers fired warning shots to keep them out.

One rickety flatbed truck was carrying a coffin. Zaffar Ali had died the night before in Peshawar, the frontier provincial capital, and his family was trying to take him home to their village to be buried.

"What choice do we have? We will spend the night here and hope tomorrow we can return to our village to bury him," the dead man's nephew said.

Among those around him, there was a mixed reaction to the military operation to rid the area of the Taliban. But all were united in their criticism of the government's failure to help those forced to flee the fighting.

Most of the displaced have sought shelter with relatives or friends, but more than 100,000 remain crowded into camps run by the government and international aid organizations.

Whether Pakistan's will to take on the militants will falter depends in part on whether people like Amina and Khan can quickly return to their homes. A protracted refugee crisis could undercut public support for the battle.

Packed into the back of a flatbed truck with nearly a dozen other women, their faces all hidden beneath burqas, Amina said: "We just want peace." The small portion of her face that was visible was dripping with sweat; her 1-year-old son squirmed beneath the folds of cloth.

Shah Bahauddin, who was shepherding 40 members of his family back to Buner, was critical of all parties in the conflict __ the government, the Taliban and the army.

"No one has given us anything in the camps and nothing to help us return," he said. The Taliban slipped into his village of Chamla several weeks ago, seizing houses and confiscating cars. "For three days they even had their own government," he said.

Bahauddin and his family sought shelter from the fighting with relatives in nearby Swabi.

"But they are poor. When we heard that Buner was open, we had to leave. They helped us so much, but we couldn't stay if we could go home," said the 65-year-old farmer, whose son sat in a wheelchair precariously positioned in the back of the family truck.

"What are they doing telling us we can come back?" he asked bitterly, interrupted by the sound of shells exploding.

Like most of the men in the convoy, Bahauddin had hoped to get home soon to harvest wheat that will soon rot in the fields. "We are poor farmers. We will lose everything," he said.

At Ambela's police station, Bacha, a 28-year veteran, said the station had been wrested from Taliban hands just two weeks earlier.

Bacha, who said the Taliban were nearby despite government claims to the contrary, said he worried about another attack and recalled last month's Taliban takeover.

It was April 28, and there were just 10 policemen in the two-room station. The best weapon among them was a Kalashnikov assault rifle, he said.

Nearly 80 Taliban emerged from the mountains, armed with rocket launchers and automatic rifles.

"They had lots of weapons. We just left," said Bacha, his gray-flecked shalwar kameeze hanging loosely on his thin frame, unbuttoned and tattered, a silver police insignia pinned crookedly on his shoulder. "What else could we do?"

Source

Labels: , , , , ,

posted @ 9:53 AM, ,

Urban Battle Looms Ahead for Pakistan in Swat

Bookmark and Share

The New York Times
By JANE PERLEZ and PIR ZUBAIR SHAH
Published: May 19, 2009

PESHAWAR, Pakistan — As the Pakistani Army squeezed the main city in Swat on Tuesday, fleeing residents described roads mined by the Taliban, indiscriminate firing by the military, and a small group of besieged government officials hanging on with dwindling food and fuel.

The city, Mingora, has been emptied of many of its 200,000 people, but a sizable population remains hemmed in there and has lived without electricity or much water for more than a week, the fleeing residents said. The people who remain are now in danger of being caught up in the looming fight for the city.

In some sections of Mingora, decomposed bodies lay untended. One man said that when he walked out of the city several days ago, dogs were chewing at four bodies that he believed were those of Taliban insurgents.

Pakistani analysts and politicians said the fight for Mingora presented a decisive test of the military’s ability to defeat the Taliban in Swat, a once popular scenic resort 100 miles from the capital, Islamabad.

Unaccustomed to urban guerrilla warfare, the military has so far concentrated on battling the militants in the rural and mountainous areas of Swat. Inside Mingora, the militants command the rooftops and the main buildings, according to residents and government officials.

In a statement issued Tuesday, the army said it had started clearing houses in Kanju, a village on the outskirts of Mingora, and residents who had left Kanju described a mounting civilian death toll.

“They will leave Mingora until last,” said Aftab Ahmed Sherpao, a former interior minister, whose political base is adjacent to the Swat area. “You have to clear each and every house, and the Taliban are going to give their own pitched battle.”

The Pakistani Army has closed Swat to outsiders and essentially ordered residents to leave. The authorities have also mostly barred journalists from entering the area, making it difficult to verify what is happening.

Government officials have said that there were only 10,000 residents left in Mingora, a city of narrow streets and close living quarters, and that those remaining were probably Taliban sympathizers. But Mr. Sherpao disputed that characterization.

At a security meeting of government officials on Tuesday, Mr. Sherpao said, he appealed to the government to allow the International Committee of the Red Cross to enter the city so that it could distribute medicine. The military rebuffed the group when it tried to deliver supplies at the end of last week, according to Red Cross officials.

The United Nations said Monday that more than one million people had fled the conflict in Swat in one of the biggest exoduses of internally displaced people in recent years.

This week, the United Nations is expected to begin asking governments to donate up to several hundred million dollars to help feed, clothe and shelter the displaced, many of whom are depending on the good will of Pakistani families who have opened their homes to them.

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton announced Tuesday that the United States would contribute $110 million in aid.

Virtually the only information on events in Swat comes from the accounts of those who have fled on foot or on trucks and buses.

In Kanju, the village adjacent to the airport, Arshad Khan Kanju, 28, a university graduate, was shot by soldiers on May 11, said his brother Mujeeb.

“There was firing outside, and he thought the Taliban had come and he went out on the veranda,” said Mujeeb Khan Kanju. That is when the military opened fire. “Arshad’s body was riddled with bullets,” his brother said.

Soldiers shot Mr. Khan Kanju even though he was clean-shaven and could not be mistaken for one of the Taliban, who favor long hair and beards, his brother said.

When a family member retrieved the body from the military, a major conceded that the soldiers had made a mistake, the brother said. “I told them if you continue killing such innocent people you’ll turn everyone into a Taliban,” he said.

Another man from Kanju, Noor ul-Wahid, said people were too afraid to collect the dead. “Dogs were eating four dead bodies” as he left Mingora last Friday, Mr. Wahid said.

Several people who had left the conflict zone said they had seen the Taliban laying land mines in the roads to stop the army from entering the city.

“They put them in the middle of the road,” said Zahoor Khan, a businessman from Mangalwar, who said he walked out of Swat three days ago. “They are not remote controlled.”

There were plenty of Taliban in the areas as he walked south past Mingora, he said, but the militants were not stopping people from leaving.

A senior government official and a contingent of police officers were holding out in a complex of buildings in Saidu Sharif, the administrative capital of Swat, adjacent to Mingora, said Javed Iqbal, the chief secretary of the North-West Frontier Province.

In the past few days, however, there were concerns for the safety of Khushal Khan, the district coordinating officer for Swat.

Efforts to reach Mr. Khan, who is in his early 30s and earned a graduate degree from Sydney University in Australia, by phone had failed in the last three to five days, said two government officials.

One government official who said he spoke to Mr. Khan five days ago said the district officer was worried about dwindling rations of food and fuel.

Elsewhere in Swat, in Peochar, the mountain stronghold where the military dropped commandos by helicopter last week, the Taliban had stashed large quantities of weapons in labyrinthine tunnels dug 80 feet deep, according to a Pakistani television reporter with the Geo channel who accompanied troops there.

The army said Tuesday that its troops were still consolidating their gains in Peochar, where the militants were putting up extremely tough resistance, officials said.

The FM radio stations that the militants have used to terrorize people with broadcasts of Taliban edicts in the past 18 months still appeared to be operating, said Afzal Khan Lala, a senior member of the Awami National Party that controls the North-West Frontier Province.

None of the half-dozen senior leaders of the Taliban in Swat had been captured, he said, expressing disappointment. “Where are they?” he said. “Swat is a very limited valley.”

Source

Labels: , , , , , , ,

posted @ 9:46 AM, ,

A war on two fronts

Bookmark and Share

Editorial, Dawn, Pakistan
By S.M. Naseem
Wednesday, 20 May, 2009

THE Pakistan Army’s sudden escalation of hostilities against the Taliban in the last two weeks, without prior preparation to prevent or minimise collateral damage, has landed the country, even if unintentionally, in its worst humanitarian crisis since its inception.

Back then, people were willing to pay any price to secure their freedom and new home. No one then had any doubts that the war for which they were laying down their lives and for which millions were abandoning their hearths and homes, even as old inhabitants ecstatically welcomed the refugees, was their own and that they were fully prepared to face and share its consequences.

A similar, if contextually different, response was witnessed during the 2005 earthquake when hundreds of thousands of refugees were forced to seek shelter, albeit temporarily, in various urban centres in the country until their homes and communities were rebuilt with government help — a task that is yet to be completed. Successive governments seem to accumulate unfinished agendas as new ones are thrust on them either by the vagaries of nature or their own follies.

The early 1980s brought us another humanitarian disaster in the form of the influx of Afghan refugees. This influx — thought to be temporary — was welcomed as a Pashtunwali gesture. It came with the safe haven we provided to Afghan warlords, militant religious extremism and the drug and Kalashnikov culture.

Things are different today as we face the second largest internal migration in our history since 1947. Although many, especially among the elite, call it the result of Pakistan’s “existentialist war”, others, even among those directly affected by the war, refuse to accept its ownership, attributing its illegitimate paternity to the US and Pakistani military establishments. The reality is, of course, much more complex than either of the two oversimplified versions, although both have some truth to them.

The fact is that large swathes of our country are today beyond the writ of the state and various insurgencies, representing legitimate and contrived grievances, dominate certain parts. Of these, the Taliban and the Baloch nationalists’ issues have acquired urgency. Although the latter has much greater political significance as an “existentialist threat” for Pakistan, as well as being a secular struggle which could transform into an Intifada of sorts, the focus currently is on the former because of US involvement and the inducement of billions of aid being promised to fight that menace. To that extent, it is, at least partly, an American war, or at best an American-army war.

Regardless of the differences regarding their genesis and motivation, there is considerable unanimity now — although differences on a common strategy still remain — that the Taliban have become a formidable threat to the integrity, progress and prosperity of the Pakistani nation and that they can’t be allowed to impose their despicable version of religion by force, as they have attempted to in Swat.

Whether it was wise on the part of the political class to allow them political space by accepting an indigenous legal system and whether the Taliban succeeded in hoodwinking the people that they wanted to dismantle an unjust socioeconomic order is now moot. Their reneging on the agreement to lay down arms and accept the writ of the constitution, which Sufi Mohammad, the Taliban intermediary, rejected as un-Islamic, and their armed intrusion into Dir and Buner, have gone against them.

True much of the blame for the fiasco lies at the door of those who negotiated and canvassed for the Nizam-i-Adl. But the army and intelligence agencies can’t be absolved of not nipping the insurgency in the bud and, more importantly, not being prepared with a plan for well-thought-through army action that would include the evacuation of civilians from the targeted area in advance. The pace and timing of the army’s action seems to have been dictated more by the need of getting financial support from Washington than by meeting the challenges in Pakistan.

If military sources are to be believed, the delayed fast-track action in Buner, Dir and Swat has already killed about a quarter of the 4,000 Taliban insurgents facing about 10,000 Pakistani troops during the last two weeks. Whether or not the tide of Taliban insurgency has been stemmed significantly, will become evident only when at least some of the trapped insurgents begin to surrender and people in the affected areas begin to trek back to their homes in sufficient numbers. However, the ISPR has been reticent about collateral damage, which independent reports indicate are high, since the techniques adopted are similar to those used by American forces in Iraq.

Currently, the second front of the battle against the Taliban — that for hearts and minds, rather than hearths and homes — is being fought in a score of refugee camps set up in the adjacent Pakhtunkhwa areas and in the countless temporary shelters all over the country and in the homes of friends and relatives. Up to two million people have been displaced and the arrangements in the refugee camps are inadequate and their management far from satisfactory — far below the standards, by no means spectacular, achieved during the 2005 earthquake. The private relief effort is stated to have exceeded the official effort by a margin of three to one.

If military action continues for much longer, citizens will get weary and the refugees will get restless and may even succumb to the lure of the Taliban’s agenda. There is, therefore, the need to upscale and remove imperfections in the public relief effort, along with increasing the intensity of military action while keeping collateral damage to a minimum. Otherwise, the Taliban will gain ground as modern-day Robin Hoods.

The management of the relief effort is far more haphazard and half-hearted than in the case of the 2005 earthquake, which unravelled without prior warning, unlike the present disaster. It is regrettable that the disaster relief lessons learnt and institutions created after the 2005 earthquake have not been invoked in the present situation.

The Pakistani Army today faces its biggest challenge in redeeming itself in the eyes of the nation since 1971 when it lost half the country and later when it got itself involved in two prolonged periods of ruling the nation, destroying democracy in the process. It has a chance to prove that it is on the same page as the civilian government to save the integrity of the nation and restore peace.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

posted @ 2:00 PM, ,


Enter your email address: