Pakistan in Media

Opinionated Media Coverage

Inside story of PPP CEC meeting

Bookmark and Share

ISLAMABAD: In the last fateful meeting of the party central executive committee, the old PPP guards surprisingly compared the present siege-like situation of President Asif Ali Zardari to that of late Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who during his incarceration days was given similar sugar coated assurances about his survival by his party leaders, just as an ‘all is well and great’ report being given today by all the president’s men.

President Zardari was reportedly told point black by Nawab Yousuf Talpur that these were the similar sycophants who were nowhere to be seen when the time of trial came and ultimately their leader was hanged.

Apparently, Talpur’s bold utterances proved only a harbinger of more to come. According to sources, after a very long time some of the senior party leaders blasted the policies and failures of their own government, and much to their pleasant surprise, they found the president, also the party co-chairman, ready to listen to them uninterrupted and without giving them a put up or shut up call. Some of the senior party leaders were said to be dissatisfied with the briefing given to them on the NRO issue and the government plans to tackle it in the days to come.

Earlier, unlike the past traditions, CEC members were also asked to give approval for the long pending reshuffling of the cabinet. The CEC empowered the president to change the portfolios of the ministers but Mr Zardari hurriedly passed on these powers to PM Yousuf Raza Gilani, who might soon announce the changes in the portfolios of the ministers. One source said, MNA Sherry Rehman and Senator Raza Rabbani were likely to rejoin the cabinet.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 8:25 AM, ,

PPP Searching for friends

Bookmark and Share

Suddenly the PPP whose prime minister was elected unanimously by parliament just over 19 months ago finds itself desperately short of friends. In a move that may deliver the PPP a very big blow, the MQM has warned that it could reconsider remaining a part of the setup. The party's leader, in a typically fiery address to a rally in Skardu, has stressed that for him principle is more important than the NRO. It is not quite clear when this turnaround came about, given that initially the MQM had not seemed too concerned over the moral dilemmas the law posed, but the stance taken now puts President Zardari in what is an extremely tight spot indeed. It is this that has compelled him to take rather desperate measures and find some way of retaining the NRO and the protection it offers. For all the government's brave words about revealing the full list of NRO beneficiaries and the denial by several politicians that they are among these, Mr Zardari and his aides are obviously acutely concerned about what an environment stripped of the NRO could bring. Legal opinion varies, but many experts agree that at least some cases against the president and others could be reopened. The idea of the ball being thrown to the courts may not go down with the presidency either.

It is possibly for these reasons that some kind of last ditch effort seems to be on to find friends. The meeting between the president and side-lined PPP leader Aitzaz Ahsan is just one manifestation of this. Mr Ahsan has reportedly been offered the post of attorney general or Punjab governor. Perhaps by bringing a respected leader of the lawyers' movement back to the PPP fold, Mr Zardari hopes to regain goodwill and end the state of isolation he finds himself in, with many members of his own party increasingly disgruntled. But the going will not be easy. The chorus of voices demanding the repeal of the 17th Amendment and the undoing of Article 58(2)(B) is rising. The president will almost inevitably find himself a toothless figure, even if he can retain his place at the presidency. The MQM will of course play a key role in this. It is one the party of Altaf Hussain is not unfamiliar with. One question is if its showdown with the president is prompted by other, behind-the-scene players who may be playing a part in the political soap opera that we now see unfolding before our eyes.
source

Labels: , ,

posted @ 9:45 PM, ,

Retreat over NRO

Bookmark and Share

After a high level meeting of the ruling alliance at the Presidency on Monday, the PPP government has decided not to bring the controversial National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO) to parliament for a vote. This is clearly a reversal but one which could have been avoided had the ruling party consulted its allies beforehand. It is quite apparent that the NRO as a bill was brought to the relevant committee of the National Assembly without making sure that all the numbers needed were in hand.

The withdrawal will not put an end to the “dangers” that the NRO represented to the map of power brought about by the 2008 general elections. After the debacle caused by an aggressive withdrawal of the MQM from the pro-NRO consensus, the next crisis in the offing is the march of the opposition to a no-confidence vote. The PML-N, whose chief is determined to start a Long March on the ordinance, is no longer averse to the thought of a mid-term change, whether through a new general election or through the ‘minus-one’ formula under a ‘national government’, possibly with Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani in the driving seat.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 7:18 PM, ,

Zardari can be impeached

Bookmark and Share

RAWALPINDI: Senior law and Constitution expert Senator SM Zafar on Tuesday said that if the report of Ansar Abbasi about the land scam, published in daily The News, was true, it could become impeachment material against President Asif Ali Zardari.

He was responding to a question at Geo News programme “Aaj Kamran Khan Kay Sath”. He said under the Article 43 of the Constitution, the president of Pakistan could not hold a profitable position.

He said according to the established world principle, the president resigns from other posts at the time of taking charge of the president office. While, he added, the report of Ansar Abbasi, published in daily The News, claimed that President Zardari was the director of a company, and had benefited rightly or wrongly from it.

Answering a question he said, the report of Ansar Abbasi could become impeachment material against President Zardari in future. He said if the report was correct, then it had impeachment aspect.

“If the president, according to the Article 47 of the Constitution, works against the Constitution, as I have mentioned the Article 43 which is also being violated. It also shows that if there are serious charges against the president, then it is impeachment material,” he remarked.

PML-N leader Senator Ishaq Dar while speaking in the same programme said that the nation wanted repeal of the 17th Amendment and after restoration of judiciary, repeal of the 17th Amendment was the main demand of the PML-N.

Senior analyst Hasan Askari said the U-turn on the NRO had badly damaged the PPP. He said the PPP had not taken other coalition parties into confidence over the NRO. He said President Zardari was taking unilateral decisions.
source

Labels: , ,

posted @ 7:00 PM, ,

Corruption cases to reopen involving top PPP politicians and bureaucrats

Bookmark and Share

ISLAMABAD: Over 100 corruption and criminal cases involving many top politicians and bureaucrats, which were settled under the controversial NRO after February 2, 2008, would automatically reopen after 25 days on Nov 28.

NAB documents and information collected from other sources reveal that not only President Asif Ali Zardari but most of his confidants and top political and bureaucratic aides benefited from the NRO after February 2, 2008, after the controversial ordinance had completed its constitutional life of 120 days.

The Presidency’s decision not to enact the NRO with effect from February 2, 2008 would reopen all the cases settled after that date as per the Supreme Court decision. Documents reveal that under the NRO reference (ref) 91/2004 against Rehman Malik, the present interior minister, for alleged misuse of authority, was closed down on March 3, 2008. On the same day, another case (ref 92/2004) against Rehman Malik for alleged receipt of two cars from Toyota Motors as illegal gratification on account of purchase of official vehicles was also closed under the NRO.
more

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 6:56 PM, ,

Parameters of coexistence

Bookmark and Share

Regardless of a legacy of confrontation, if the two main political forces in the country are unable to define the parameters of their coexistence, the rest will become entirely secondary

Consider this: Pakistan’s Interior Minister Rehman Malik was on a visit to Saudi Arabia last week followed by another visitor, Pakistan’s former President Pervez Musharraf who arrived for his audience with King Abdullah. And now we have news reports that the PMLN chief Mian Nawaz Sharif is likely to fly to the same destination fairly soon.
more

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 7:40 AM, ,

PPP and Judiciary

Bookmark and Share

NEITHER President Zardari nor Prime Minister Gilani wasted any time in welcoming the Supreme Court’s short order declaring the Nov 3, 2007 emergency unconstitutional, and terming it a triumph of democratic principles.

The order was described as a negation and rejection of dictatorship and its actions, and was called a success of the principles for which the PPP had fought and its chairperson and countless workers laid down their lives. The verdict was called a good omen for the future of democracy.
more

Labels: , ,

posted @ 2:44 PM, ,

Zardari Nawz Marathon Talks

Bookmark and Share

The News International,Pakistan, Saturday, July 18, 2009
Zardari, Nawaz agree to repeal 17th Amendment; PML-N Quaid wants PPP to consult legal experts on Musharraf’s trial; expresses concern over price-hike, drone attacks, Balochistan situation; seeks amendments to LGO; Zardari assures Nawaz of accommodating PML-N suggestions.

LAHORE: President Asif Ali Zardari and PML-N Quaid Nawaz Sharif, during their marathon meeting here on Friday, reached consensus on repealing the 17th Amendment, securing the reserved seats for women and the joint electorate in the light of an accord, reached between the two parties under the Charter of Democracy.

The PML-N leader reportedly also asked the president to improve the government’s performance or else growing public anger might pose a grave threat to democracy in the country. The two leaders, along with their close aides, had a lunch together at Nawaz Sharif’s Raiwind residence and discussed a number of issues of national and international significance.
More

Labels: , , , ,

posted @ 11:15 AM, ,

A piece of paper?

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan, Sunday, July 05, 2009
The PML-N chief has said the much heralded Charter of Democracy (CoD) signed between his party and the PPP had been reduced to nothing more than a 'piece of paper'. Mian Nawaz Sharif, speaking in London, certainly has grounds for his words. The terms of the CoD in fact seem to have been largely forgotten by the ruling party. Today, on the 17 amendment that the PPP had once sworn to do away with, even the prime minister, who would benefit most if it was scrapped, speaks of the need to maintain a 'balance of powers.' Evidently the party has changed its line on this issue.
More

Labels: , , ,

posted @ 9:39 AM, ,

PPP diehards donate blood on BB’s birthday

Bookmark and Share

Daily Times, Pakistan, Monday, June 22, 2009
KARACHI: On an appeal made by President Asif Ali Zardari, thousands of PPP donated blood for the Pakistan Army on the 56th birth anniversary of PPP’s slain chairwoman Benazir Bhutto, on Sunday.
More

Labels: , ,

posted @ 11:53 AM, ,

PPP, PML-N resort to accusations, mud-slinging

Bookmark and Share

The News International, Pakistan, Friday, June 19, 2009
PML-N’s Khwaja Asif’s remarks against President Zardari triggered strong protest from the PPP legislators who in turn targeted the PML-N leadership. The speaker had to expunge remarks against the president.

Khwaja Asif accused President Zardari of bringing back politics of confrontation, saying the advocate-general of Sindh has presented the pardon documents in the court on the instructions of President Zardari. “If they continue character assassination of our leadership then we will also tell the people how Farooq H Naek brought the NRO before us to give indemnity to Gen Musharraf,” he added. He said the president lacks credibility and no body trusts him.
More

Labels: , ,

posted @ 9:54 AM, ,

The sole struggle (PPP-PML N Cooperation)

Bookmark and Share

Daily Times, Pakistan
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
view, William B Milam

The question remains whether the PPP-PMLN solidarity on this can hold beyond the army’s campaign in Swat. There is much more territory to regain and hold. Remember, one of the principal tenets of counter-insurgency military strategy is to take and hold territory

A couple of weeks ago while I was in the United Kingdom to promote my recently-published book, I found myself facing an audience at one of England’s ancient and most prestigious universities. The questions were intelligent and well-informed. One very bright student challenged my assertion (better explained in the book than in my presentation, perhaps) that one of Pakistan’s fundamental problems is that it has not yet, 62 years after its creation, settled on a national identity.

My contention is that two mutually exclusive competing visions of the Pakistani state/nation are still vying for dominance. The one we in the West know best is that of the state’s founder, Mohammed Ali Jinnah, who outlined on August 11, 1947, a vision of a secular, tolerant, progressive state/nation.

The one we know less well, but which may even predate at least the articulation of Jinnah’s liberal version, is the much more restrictive vision of an Islamic state which had been the objective of the Islamists and Islamist Parties who were part of the Pakistan Movement even before Partition. Possibly because Jinnah died so soon after Pakistan’s creation, the identity of the state/nation was never agreed and remains up for grabs to this day.

Bits and pieces of Jinnah’s vision have been, for sixty years, consistently traded away for political gain by both civilian and military leaders of the country in what I call “Faustian Bargains”. I have written in this column several times about these deals, including that the “Swat peace deal” was simply the latest version. It has been many years, I suspect, since the secular aspect of Jinnah’s vision was a remotely possible element of a Pakistani national identity. Some, perhaps even that British student, may think the fight is over and the Islamist vision has won.

The current violent military struggle against Islamist extremists in Swat, and perhaps beyond, is probably only indirectly related to the question of Pakistan’s unsettled national identity. It is not clear that, even if Jinnah’s vision had been adopted and had guided the state’s civilian and military political leaders from the beginning, there would be no such struggle in Pakistan given the history of the last thirty years — the creation and arming of the mujahideen to fight in Afghanistan, and the jihadists in Kashmir (unless one argues that leaders guided by Jinnah’s vision would not have followed such policies).

The Taliban and their allies appear to have a strategic aim of carving out a sanctuary in Pakistan, to make it easier and safer to plan and launch operations in the region and against the West rather than any overall political strategy relating to Pakistan’s national identity. That the Taliban who overreached in Swat and Buner represent such an extreme and repugnant version of the Islamic state is, perhaps, a major reason that public opinion seems to have swung to favour military action to push them back and eliminate their threat to the state.

The view put forward by the British student was that the real problem of Pakistan’s national identity is that the country is a patchwork of different and often competing nationalities, ethnic and language groups, and cultures. Very little has been done to try to incorporate these disparate elements into a national framework, and there remains great tension among them, and between them and the central government. This view is, of course, fully consistent with Pakistani history, as well as current reality; we need only refer to the long-running insurgency in Balochistan as evidence. And there is plenty more if we need it.

There is much to argue for this view. Certainly most historians have pointed out that this heterogeneity is a critical problem that has inhibited building a Pakistani nation. “Nationalities in search of a nation” is one of the first headlines in the book I was talking about. In fact, provincial, ethnic, or language identifications seem increasingly to be elements of disunity in Pakistan. There are, of course, religious differences among nationalities, ethnic and linguistic groups that figure in this disunity, but there are equally — perhaps even greater — elements of provincial, ethnic, and linguistic pride and prerogative involved. These may be exacerbated by economic and social disparities.

But the question of national unity is not necessarily the same as the question of national identity. Bangladesh, with a common language and homogeneous culture, the hallmarks national unity, also has no commonly agreed national identity — although it did not start that way as did Pakistan.

The two versions are, in fact the basis of the two major political parties — the BNP version, a geographic and religious identity, was invented by the first military government to counteract the original Awami League primordial version based on the common language and culture. In reality, these two versions have come much closer together over the past twenty years.

It seems clear to me that the struggle over Pakistan’s national identity fundamentally involves religion. After all, Pakistan was created as a religious sanctuary, and the kind of sanctuary it would be is at the core of the identity problem. That must be why Jinnah, perhaps a little late, endeavoured to set Pakistan on a secular course at the beginning. He may also have been trying to make up for his earlier ambiguity on the nature of the Pakistani state he was creating during the period when he was seeking to hold the Muslim League together for the 1946 election.

When I think back on my days in Pakistan, and beyond the sheer pleasure of the many great friendships I made (many of which I still maintain from afar), the words that ring loudest in my memory are those of a senior Pakistani diplomat who I admired but did not get to know well enough. In what I suspect was an unguarded moment, he said to me once, Pakistan is in a desperate “struggle for its soul”. Almost ten years later, I have heard similar words from others, but, until the last few days, almost never from political or military leaders.

Now, the government and the army have taken up the fight against the Taliban in Swat with intensity and, as far as I can tell, intelligence. The question in my mind is whether they suddenly believe that this really is a struggle for Pakistan’s soul. If so, what led them to change their minds from just a few months ago when they were willing to try one more Faustian Bargain at the expense of the people of Swat?

And what about the rest of the political class? The news out of the all-parties conference was not reassuring. An indirect backing of the government’s policy, we are told. In order to get consensus, all reference to the Taliban and to the military operation in Swat was removed. On the other hand, the PMLN appears to back the PPP government, at least for now, and that is good. Reading further, I find that if there had been a vote in the Assembly on a resolution backing the operation, it would have won by a large majority.

The question remains whether the PPP-PMLN solidarity on this can hold beyond the army’s campaign in Swat. There is much more territory to regain and hold. Remember, one of the principal tenets of counter-insurgency military strategy is to take and hold territory. It took the US Army quite a while to re-learn that in Iraq, having forgotten it once it left Vietnam almost forty years ago.

The Pakistan army certainly has the manpower to undertake that strategy; but does it have the will, and the public backing? And will it have such backing as well as the will to reduce its forces along the eastern border in order to hold the state’s reacquired territory? Or will Pakistan have to go through all this once again in six months or so?

Source

Labels: , ,

posted @ 9:15 AM, ,


Enter your email address: