IDP (Internally Displaced Persons) issues (Swat Region)
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Editorial, The News International, Pakistan
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
The NWFP government says there are now at least 700,000 IDPs in the country. Many have yet to be registered. While concern is growing over their plight, and agencies including the UNHCR and the ICRC have made appeals for immediate help, there are many issues that need to be considered. One of these is that the vast majority of IDPs are opting to move in with relatives or rent out accommodation, even when the rates are exorbitant given that many of those forced out of homes are no longer working and have only limited savings. This means the strategy of setting up camp villages which have already appeared in Mardan, Swabi and other places across NWFP is somewhat less effective than it may have been in other circumstances. There are cultural reasons linked to the behaviour of the IDPs. Even though some concede they would have better access to food and other forms of relief at camps, they argue that their women observe 'pardah' and cannot be put up in tents living next door to strangers. The issue of blood rivalry has also been brought up, and the displaced people say they fear that in a camp they may be vulnerable to enemies who may seek to extract revenge.
These factors may seem irrelevant given the scale of suffering we see and the need for basic items such as food and water. But the fact is that they matter deeply to those affected. For some at least the simpler issue of human dignity also plays a part. Living independently is for them preferable to living on what they perceive is charity. Our government needs to step in, help attune international relief teams to these realities and find means to work around them. At the moment we have a situation where up to 20 or 30 people are living in single-room apartments. Some means of offering them assistance, perhaps in the form of jobs, or compensation for what they have suffered must be found.
Some thought must also be given to those who have opted to stay on in their homes or have had no choice but to do so. Severe food shortages are being reported in Mingora, medicines are unavailable and almost all doctors have left the city. Some plan must also be put in place to help the people caught up in the midst of fighting. Many of them are the most impoverished residents of war-hit towns and villages, who lack the resources to flee. These people, like the IDPs, must not be punished for their helplessness. In the months ahead we may find that the people of the northern areas hold the key to their future. All that is possible must therefore be done to show them they have not been abandoned and that all that is possible is being done to ensure their suffering is as limited as possible. A failure to do so would benefit the Taliban.
These factors may seem irrelevant given the scale of suffering we see and the need for basic items such as food and water. But the fact is that they matter deeply to those affected. For some at least the simpler issue of human dignity also plays a part. Living independently is for them preferable to living on what they perceive is charity. Our government needs to step in, help attune international relief teams to these realities and find means to work around them. At the moment we have a situation where up to 20 or 30 people are living in single-room apartments. Some means of offering them assistance, perhaps in the form of jobs, or compensation for what they have suffered must be found.
Some thought must also be given to those who have opted to stay on in their homes or have had no choice but to do so. Severe food shortages are being reported in Mingora, medicines are unavailable and almost all doctors have left the city. Some plan must also be put in place to help the people caught up in the midst of fighting. Many of them are the most impoverished residents of war-hit towns and villages, who lack the resources to flee. These people, like the IDPs, must not be punished for their helplessness. In the months ahead we may find that the people of the northern areas hold the key to their future. All that is possible must therefore be done to show them they have not been abandoned and that all that is possible is being done to ensure their suffering is as limited as possible. A failure to do so would benefit the Taliban.
Labels: Internally Displaced Persons, Pakistan, Swat, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 12:47 PM,
,
![]()
Pakistan military faces up to humanitarian crisis (Swat Region)
May 12, 2009
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan (CNN) -- Pakistan's military is dealing with more than a million Pakistanis who have been displaced by fighting since last year, a military spokesman said Tuesday.
The military has set up headquarters to manage the 1.3 million internally displaced people, spokesman Gen. Athar Abbas said.
That number includes 500,000 Pakistanis who were uprooted from their homes since August, before the latest military push against Taliban militants in the country's northeastern region, he said.
The army has set up hospitals in many of the refugee camps and plans to build camps near the conflict zone, he said.
Pakistan's military is continuing an offensive against the Taliban along its western border with Afghanistan, particularly in the Swat Valley.
The military has been releasing regular reports saying it has killed Taliban militants in the region, but it has produced little evidence of the successes it claims. Journalists have not been permitted to observe the offensive and the army has not shown bodies of the militants it says it has killed.
Curfews have been imposed in the conflict zone, but are relaxed periodically to allow civilians to travel. It is not unusual now to see rickshaws and cargo trucks filled with fleeing civilians, rolling down Pakistan's main east-west highway.
Vehicles are not allowed back into the region, which has led to a shortage for those trying to leave.
On Sunday, at least 25 boys stranded at the Khpal Kor Foundation orphanage in Swat Valley had to flee the district capital, Mingora, on foot, according to director Mohammed Ali.
He said local government officials told him there were no vehicles to evacuate the children.
The 175-kilometer (110-mile) journey from Mingora to the western city of Peshawar normally takes about three hours by car. The boys walked for several hours, but had to spend the night in a madrassa -- a religious school -- outside of Mingora, because authorities had re-established the curfew.
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan (CNN) -- Pakistan's military is dealing with more than a million Pakistanis who have been displaced by fighting since last year, a military spokesman said Tuesday.
The military has set up headquarters to manage the 1.3 million internally displaced people, spokesman Gen. Athar Abbas said.
That number includes 500,000 Pakistanis who were uprooted from their homes since August, before the latest military push against Taliban militants in the country's northeastern region, he said.
The army has set up hospitals in many of the refugee camps and plans to build camps near the conflict zone, he said.
Pakistan's military is continuing an offensive against the Taliban along its western border with Afghanistan, particularly in the Swat Valley.
The military has been releasing regular reports saying it has killed Taliban militants in the region, but it has produced little evidence of the successes it claims. Journalists have not been permitted to observe the offensive and the army has not shown bodies of the militants it says it has killed.
Curfews have been imposed in the conflict zone, but are relaxed periodically to allow civilians to travel. It is not unusual now to see rickshaws and cargo trucks filled with fleeing civilians, rolling down Pakistan's main east-west highway.
Vehicles are not allowed back into the region, which has led to a shortage for those trying to leave.
On Sunday, at least 25 boys stranded at the Khpal Kor Foundation orphanage in Swat Valley had to flee the district capital, Mingora, on foot, according to director Mohammed Ali.
He said local government officials told him there were no vehicles to evacuate the children.
The 175-kilometer (110-mile) journey from Mingora to the western city of Peshawar normally takes about three hours by car. The boys walked for several hours, but had to spend the night in a madrassa -- a religious school -- outside of Mingora, because authorities had re-established the curfew.
Labels: Army Operation, Internally Displaced Persons, Pakistan, Swat, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 11:03 AM,
,
![]()
A national tragedy (Swat Region)
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Editorial
The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
As the fierce military operation continues in Swat and other areas, tens of thousands of people continue to flee the fighting. The brief lifting of a curfew imposed in Swat saw hundreds of desperate families pile belongings into trucks, vans, cars or hand-pushed trolleys and try to make it down to safer locations, even if they had to do so on foot. The plight of Pakistan's displaced people is terrible to witness. Already, the immense humanitarian crisis unfolding in our midst has been taken note of by international organizations in many places. Yet there is still a kind of disconnect between the people forced to take shelter where they can and the mainstream of society in our country. This is a continuation of the isolation of different parts of the Federation that began some three decades ago and was deliberately created in order to maximize the power of an autocrat. It is this mental distance, which extends far further than the actual number of kilometres, which has allowed militants to take hold of certain areas in the first place, while the rest of us waited and watched, often with indifference. Now we seem content to be mere onlookers once again while small children driven from homes by no fault of their own scramble for a few crumbs of food or women who till now have lived lives of dignity scrounge through garbage heaps in the hope of finding something to feed famished families who struggle to survive.
The catastrophe is one that in magnitude is as vast as the earthquake of 2005. So far no figures are being given for civilian casualties, but we all know, in our hearts of hearts, that some non-combatants at least will die. The kind of war being fought means this is in fact almost impossible to avoid – though of course the government must attempt to minimize what we have learned to call 'collateral damage'. It is the danger of such a death that has brought desperate people pouring out of homes. We need mobilization of the kind seen three and a half years ago, in the days that followed the quake. We need everyone in a position to give or to help in other ways to be involved in the effort to prevent still more misery for displaced persons. The need to avert human suffering is of course irrefutable, but the fact also is that we need to create a 'connect' between people from the northern areas and the mainstream of our country. Building bridges that can close the existing chasms between different parts of our country may eventually prove just as crucial to winning the war against militants as the actual military operation. Success on both fronts is indeed interlinked and this reality should not be ignored. We need action to help displaced people, so that the process of winning over hearts coincides with that of regaining control over tracts of territory and may be the factor that enables the state to retain a grasp of these lands over a longer frame of time.
The News International, Pakistan
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
As the fierce military operation continues in Swat and other areas, tens of thousands of people continue to flee the fighting. The brief lifting of a curfew imposed in Swat saw hundreds of desperate families pile belongings into trucks, vans, cars or hand-pushed trolleys and try to make it down to safer locations, even if they had to do so on foot. The plight of Pakistan's displaced people is terrible to witness. Already, the immense humanitarian crisis unfolding in our midst has been taken note of by international organizations in many places. Yet there is still a kind of disconnect between the people forced to take shelter where they can and the mainstream of society in our country. This is a continuation of the isolation of different parts of the Federation that began some three decades ago and was deliberately created in order to maximize the power of an autocrat. It is this mental distance, which extends far further than the actual number of kilometres, which has allowed militants to take hold of certain areas in the first place, while the rest of us waited and watched, often with indifference. Now we seem content to be mere onlookers once again while small children driven from homes by no fault of their own scramble for a few crumbs of food or women who till now have lived lives of dignity scrounge through garbage heaps in the hope of finding something to feed famished families who struggle to survive.
The catastrophe is one that in magnitude is as vast as the earthquake of 2005. So far no figures are being given for civilian casualties, but we all know, in our hearts of hearts, that some non-combatants at least will die. The kind of war being fought means this is in fact almost impossible to avoid – though of course the government must attempt to minimize what we have learned to call 'collateral damage'. It is the danger of such a death that has brought desperate people pouring out of homes. We need mobilization of the kind seen three and a half years ago, in the days that followed the quake. We need everyone in a position to give or to help in other ways to be involved in the effort to prevent still more misery for displaced persons. The need to avert human suffering is of course irrefutable, but the fact also is that we need to create a 'connect' between people from the northern areas and the mainstream of our country. Building bridges that can close the existing chasms between different parts of our country may eventually prove just as crucial to winning the war against militants as the actual military operation. Success on both fronts is indeed interlinked and this reality should not be ignored. We need action to help displaced people, so that the process of winning over hearts coincides with that of regaining control over tracts of territory and may be the factor that enables the state to retain a grasp of these lands over a longer frame of time.
Labels: Army Operation, Internally Displaced Persons, Pakistan, Swat, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 11:24 AM,
,
![]()
We may be defeated by refugee camps
Monday, May 11, 2009
Daily Times, Pakistan
Monday, May 11, 2009
Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani says the Swat operation is a fight for the “survival of Pakistan”. True. But we could be defeated in this fight by the developing crisis of the refugee camps in Mardan and elsewhere in the NWFP unless we do some emergency reorganisation. When the provincial government asked the people of the Malakand region to leave their homes to give the Pakistan Army a chance to take on the Taliban without too much collateral damage, the local population readily agreed. But their reception at the camps is turning out to be a trauma they did not anticipate.
The camps have been hurriedly put together in Mardan, Swabi and other places in the NWFP, and first reports are not very heartening. Around 200,000 have moved out of the target areas; an additional 300,000 are on the move and are expected to reach the camps by the beginning of the week. They will have joined the earlier 500,000 that fled the conflict zone and have been absorbed in various parts of the province, including the old deserted refugee camps used by the Afghan refugees in the past. That makes a total of one million refugees. The NWFP government projects a figure of 1.5 million as the war in Swat goes into attrition.
The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) disagrees with the numbers on the basis of registration because registration is the only way you can officially compute the size of displacement. It is true that many Swatis and people from other areas have moved in with their relatives outside the region but the coming flood of refugees is mostly going to be looked after by the state of Pakistan. The prime minister has already given Rs 1 billion to the NWFP government but it is organisation and expert handling that is missing. The first images appearing on the TV channels tell us that both are in short supply.
If this is the case, we may be defeated by the Taliban because of the refugee camps. We had a much better record of handling the displaced persons after the 2005 earthquake in Azad Kashmir and parts of the NWFP. Have we forgotten the lessons? The 2005 earthquake was a sudden natural calamity and we could not have organised rescue and settlement beforehand. Adverse publicity of government performance went on for weeks before organisation caught up with the homeless. Beyond 2005, we had decades of experience of handling the Afghan refugees most of whom were lodged in the NWFP. Where has that expertise gone?
Read more
Monday, May 11, 2009
Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani says the Swat operation is a fight for the “survival of Pakistan”. True. But we could be defeated in this fight by the developing crisis of the refugee camps in Mardan and elsewhere in the NWFP unless we do some emergency reorganisation. When the provincial government asked the people of the Malakand region to leave their homes to give the Pakistan Army a chance to take on the Taliban without too much collateral damage, the local population readily agreed. But their reception at the camps is turning out to be a trauma they did not anticipate.
The camps have been hurriedly put together in Mardan, Swabi and other places in the NWFP, and first reports are not very heartening. Around 200,000 have moved out of the target areas; an additional 300,000 are on the move and are expected to reach the camps by the beginning of the week. They will have joined the earlier 500,000 that fled the conflict zone and have been absorbed in various parts of the province, including the old deserted refugee camps used by the Afghan refugees in the past. That makes a total of one million refugees. The NWFP government projects a figure of 1.5 million as the war in Swat goes into attrition.
The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) disagrees with the numbers on the basis of registration because registration is the only way you can officially compute the size of displacement. It is true that many Swatis and people from other areas have moved in with their relatives outside the region but the coming flood of refugees is mostly going to be looked after by the state of Pakistan. The prime minister has already given Rs 1 billion to the NWFP government but it is organisation and expert handling that is missing. The first images appearing on the TV channels tell us that both are in short supply.
If this is the case, we may be defeated by the Taliban because of the refugee camps. We had a much better record of handling the displaced persons after the 2005 earthquake in Azad Kashmir and parts of the NWFP. Have we forgotten the lessons? The 2005 earthquake was a sudden natural calamity and we could not have organised rescue and settlement beforehand. Adverse publicity of government performance went on for weeks before organisation caught up with the homeless. Beyond 2005, we had decades of experience of handling the Afghan refugees most of whom were lodged in the NWFP. Where has that expertise gone?
Read more
Labels: Army Operation, Internally Displaced Persons, Pakistan, Refugees, Swat, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 5:37 PM,
,
![]()
