The Kingdom in Pakistan
Saturday, June 20, 2009
COMMENT: Saleem H Ali
During my last visit to Lahore when I interviewed various progressive scholars, they also expressed the strongest concern about America’s unflinching support for Saudi Arabia’s policies, which made them more suspicious of the West’s resolve in tackling extremism.
The assassination of Dr Sarfraz Naeemi at a prominent madrassa in Lahore marks a turning point in Pakistan’s civil strife. The Taliban profess to be “pure” Sunni Muslims, and have targeted Shia mosques and seminaries many times before. However, Maulana Naeemi is the first notable Sunni scholar to be murdered by the Taliban.
More
Labels: Islamization, Madrassahs, Saudi Arabia, Sectarionism, Wahhabi Islam
posted @ 9:43 AM,
,
![]()
Re-socialising Pakistan
Sunday, June 7, 2009
ANALYSIS: Dr Hasan-Askari Rizvi
Sunday, June 07, 2009
Pakistan has lost over a generation to Islamic orthodoxy and militancy. By now this generation has reached middle-level positions in the government, security services and private sector.
The Swat operation has effectively countered arguments that the civilian government and the military lacked the will and capability to check the Taliban’s assault on the Pakistani state and society. Security forces seem to have dislodged the Taliban from most of the Swat valley and the major thrust of the operation is expected to be over before the end of June. Although some military presence will have to be maintained in the area for the coming six months to a year for the civil administration to take control of the situation and the displaced people to return their homes safely.
The success in Swat will give greater confidence to security personnel and discourage new recruits from joining the Taliban. In the past, people joined various militant groups, especially the Taliban, because of organisational support and the promise of power and territory.
Read More
Labels: Extremism, Islamization, Military Operation, Swat Operation, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 10:04 AM,
,
![]()
What do they (Taliban) want?
Monday, June 1, 2009
COMMENT: Syed Mansoor Hussain
I have often asked many of my friends that have a soft corner for the Taliban about what exactly the Taliban want within Pakistan. Other than anti-Americanism and some vague mutterings about sharia law, nobody has been able to answer my question
One of the great problems of modern times is that many of our attitudes are based not on well thought out principles but rather on a visceral response to what we see on TV. As such, to the West, Muslims are what they do and that is of course terrorism and extremism. For the Muslims, what the United States does is drone attacks and daisy-cutters, Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo.
For most people in this part of the world, the US-led wars in Iraq and Afghanistan seem to be all-out wars against Muslims and thus by proxy against Islam. The reverse is that for most people in the West, Muslims represent 9/11, suicide bombings, beheadings of ‘non-believers’, and floggings of ‘errant’ women; all this being an obvious negation of what western civilisation stands for
Both sides are right and both sides are wrong. The United States justifies its actions against Muslims through national interest based on ‘homeland security’, while Muslims defend their actions based on what to them seems an unjust and excessive US response to terrorism, both perceived and real.
Soon after the fall of the USSR and the emergence of the United States as the sole superpower in what were arguably more ‘innocent’ times, Francis Fukuyama came out with his concept of ‘the end of history’ and Samuel Huntington presented his thesis about the ‘clash of civilisations’. Fukuyama felt that western-style liberal democracy had triumphed and would forever be the paradigm for governance.
Huntington argued that after the end of the Cold War, future conflicts would be civilisational and not ideological. He rather arbitrarily divided the world into different ‘civilisations’ that in his opinion would vie for dominance with each other. Much of the nineties were spent by academics and intellectuals arguing against this proposition, Edward Said and Amartya Sen prominent among them.
With the new century came two major man-made disasters, the Supreme Court-directed election of George W Bush as President of the United States, and 9/11. The confluence of these two factors brought the Bush Doctrine, which essentially accepted Fukuyama’s point about the supremacy of western democracy and made it a part of official US policy to introduce such democracy, even through the use of force if needed, in the Middle East.
Also in line with the Huntington point of view, the Bush administration embarked on a ‘war on terror’, which was a thinly disguised war against Islam and the Muslims, using at times ambiguous terms like ‘Islamo-facism’ to justify their actions. Countries like India and Israel that had long standing territorial disputes with neighbouring Muslim countries immediately jumped on this ‘war of civilisations’ bandwagon.
With the election of Barack Obama, some sense is being restored to US foreign policy but too much harm has been done. Disentanglement in Iraq and the pacification of Afghanistan are difficult end points and might preoccupy the Obama administration for some years.
Repairing relations with Muslims in general might even take longer but will eventually happen if the US follows the stated objectives of President Obama in this context. He has already debunked the war of civilisations idea and has it seems given up on imposing western-style democracy in the Middle East by force.
As a liberal I have always tried my best to understand and, if possible, even accept points of view that are contrary to my beliefs. This attitude is of course dependent on an abiding belief that most people are intrinsically good and try to do what is not only best for themselves but also for people around them. And more importantly on the idea that there is always more than one way to solve almost any problem.
However, I could not, even after trying my utmost, find any redeeming value in the policies of the Bush administration. The Bush presidency is fortunately over. Almost the entire world is now rooting for Barack Obama to succeed and undo the harm done to the US and the rest of the world by the misguided policies of the Bush-Cheney duo.
As I sit in Lahore a few days after the terrorist attacks here, in Peshawar and elsewhere, and at the same time read about the army action in Swat, many of my pre-conceived notions as a liberal are being severely put to test once again. When I came to Pakistan a few years ago I was very pleasantly surprised that I got along famously with many people that I would have thought of as religious extremists.
Frankly, if I am asked today whom would I trust more in Pakistan, a devout practicing Muslim or a westernised liberal member of our self-styled ‘civil society’, I will go with the former every time!
But what the Taliban stand for is still a mystery to me. Are they a populist movement using religion to establish control over parts of Pakistan or is it the other way around, and are they really a religious group using populist anti-imperialist rhetoric to achieve the same result?
In this connection, I have often asked many of my friends that have a soft corner for the Taliban about what exactly the Taliban want within Pakistan. Other than anti-Americanism and some vague mutterings about sharia law, nobody has been able to answer my question in a satisfactory manner. As far as the talking heads on TV are concerned, they are entirely clueless.
The Taliban do not fit into either the ideological or the civilisational paradigm of conflict and thus essentially negate both the Fukuyama and the Huntington points of view. Or perhaps they really stand for nothing and are just a ‘rabble without a cause’. That might then be why, in the crunch, most Pakistanis have come out in support of the army action against them.
Syed Mansoor Hussain has practised and taught medicine in the US. He can be reached at smhmbbs70@yahoo.com
Source
Labels: Islamization, Militancy, Religion, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 9:58 AM,
,
![]()
Khalifas from the hills
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Comment, Feisal Naqvi
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
These people deserve to have war waged on them because they reject our Constitution, because they reject the values which Pakistan was founded upon, and because they are trying to stuff a different legal system down the throats of unwilling citizens
People who oppose the ongoing operation in Swat normally make two types of arguments.
The first argument is practical, that military force should only be utilised as a last resort and that this is not the time.
The second argument is philosophical. As one news anchor put it to me, how can we oppose the imposition of sharia law in Swat when Jinnah founded Pakistan in the name of Islam?
The essence of the first argument is that using the army to crush militants is the equivalent of using a sledgehammer to kill a fly. So while it may be effective, military action also comes with a massive cost. Innocent people get killed, families get displaced and entire towns get destroyed.
The answer to this argument is provided, however, by the military action itself. Operation Rah-e-Rast has been underway for almost four weeks. Sixty soldiers have died in the fighting while, according to ISPR, more than 1,100 militants have been killed. And yet, the operation is far from over. As I write these words, soldiers of the Pakistan Army are going door to door in Mingora, trying to blast out the militants who have been using 20,000 Swatis as human shields. And as for the financial cost, who knows?
The ongoing military operation is therefore self-evidently not excessive. Had that been the case, the operation would already have been over.
Opponents of military action can respond in one of three ways. The first is to argue that the army is incompetent. The second is to argue that the entire operation is a sham, the product of a giant conspiracy between Mossad, the CIA and RAW to break up the country and steal Pakistan’s nuclear weapons. And the third is to say that the army was sent in too soon.
I hold no brief for the Army and I know very little about its competence. But to paraphrase Donald Rumsfeld, you fight with the army you have, not with the army you want. Since we have no other army, accusing the army of incompetence is neither here nor there. Logically, the only other alternative would have been to invite American forces over from Afghanistan to invade Swat for us. In the absence of any support for that option, we have no option but to stick with General Kayani and his men.
So far as the grand conspiracies are concerned, I have no doubt that the CIA, Mossad and RAW would all breathe easier at night if we did not have nuclear weapons. But the fact that they do not want us to have nuclear weapons does not mean that they want to break up Pakistan. An exploded Pakistan would be exponentially more problematic for the international community than Pakistan in its current state.
If anything, the heads of CIA, Mossad and RAW are all praying to their respective deities to keep Pakistan solvent and stable because that is the only way our weapons will stay in sane hands as opposed to being in the hands of those who think that a nuclear exchange is a good idea because all the Muslims who die in the resulting holocaust will go straight to Paradise.
The final contention is that we should have waited longer. My question is: why? Is it not serious enough when a group of armed men rejects our Constitution, attacks our army and kills our citizens? And if that is not the issue, what would extra time have bought us? If anything, extra time would have given greater opportunity to the militants to entrench their positions.
I come now to the question of morality: how do I justify making war on those who are supposedly seeking only to fulfil Pakistan’s destiny?
Simply put, Pakistan’s destiny was not — and is not — to serve as the handmaiden for morons. Mohammad Ali Jinnah was not just a lawyer but one of the finest lawyers produced in the entire history of British India. His vision for Pakistan was not one in which self-proclaimed khalifas descended from the hills to unilaterally impose a vision of Islam in which the worship of God was reduced to beards of stipulated lengths and blowing up women’s schools.
At the same time, I freely concede that it is the prerogative of a sovereign nation to decide how it wants to govern itself. And if the majority of the people in this country decide through some democratic process that they actually want to be governed by Sufi Muhammad and his ilk, so be it. But they have not done so. Instead, whenever they have been given the option, the people of this country have resoundingly rejected religious parties. Pakistanis have drafted three constitutions for themselves: not one of them has set up a theocratic state.
So, Mr Anchorman, here is my answer: these people deserve to have war waged on them because they reject our Constitution, because they reject the values which Pakistan was founded upon, and because they are trying to stuff a different legal system down the throats of unwilling citizens.
Good enough for you?
Source
Labels: Islamist Parties, Islamization, Swat Operation
posted @ 9:52 AM,
,
![]()
Redeeming Pakistan’s madrassas
Saturday, May 23, 2009
May 23, 2009
COMMENT: Saleem H Ali
Although some of the radical madrassas will still need to be weeded out, embracing Islamic education with an integrated reform strategy is more likely to reduce militancy, rather than lamenting madrassas as arcane institutions
As policy-makers and the media abroad agonise over the situation in Pakistan’s Swat valley, madrassas are back on the front page in papers such as The New York Times. The linkage between extremism and education should be fairly obvious but it seems to still elude most analysts. Indeed the word “Taliban” means “students” in Pashto, suggesting an inherent connection of these militants with some form of “learning”.
Incendiary information at these Islamic seminaries is once again being considered both a symptom and a cause of Pakistan’s problems. The latest mantra appears to be that because government schools have failed, madrassas are filling a social void that offers free education and sustenance for the rural poor but causes massive radicalisation at the same time.
Madrassas in Pakistan are certainly a matter of concern but rather than finding ways to diminish their recruitment, they need to be engaged and internally reformed. These seminaries already have a major physical and financial infrastructure in the country that can be harnessed positively alongside investments in government schools.
Only four years ago, famed terrorism analysts Peter Bergen (among the few western journalists to have interviewed Osama bin Laden) and Swaty Pandey had argued in The New York Times that concern over Islamic education was all a ‘madrassa myth’. Basing their analysis on a controversial World Bank study (co-authored by two Pakistani-American academics) about the actual number of madrassas in Pakistan, Bergen and Pandey had argued that “while madrassas are an important issue in education and development in the Muslim world, they are not and should not be considered a threat to the United States” because of their relatively small number and since terrorists who attacked the West had largely not been educated in madrassas.
However, as many of the suicide bombers in recent months have been traced back to madrassas, the pendulum has swung again, as now analysts discover that civil strife in Afghanistan and Pakistan can be just as dangerous for Western interests. Focusing on the core problem of curricular reform can provide us a path out of this ambivalence about madrassas.
While growing up in Pakistan, I attended a private English-medium school but every afternoon, I would also receive Islamic learning from a religious scholar who hailed from a prominent madrassa in Lahore. As I reflect back on that time, the core problem of contemporary Islamic education remains a general antipathy towards critical thinking.
Similar concerns have existed in other religions as well, but Islamic schools in Pakistan have contended with a host of circumstances that compounded these challenges. The sectarian divide between Shias and Sunnis in Pakistan was accentuated by funding from Iran and Saudi Arabia to specific strains of madrassas, particularly in southern Punjab. Exclusionary doctrines rather than pluralistic interpretations of Islamic texts were preached by both sides to gain more adherents. Religious political parties as well as the Pakistani government and security organisations capitalised on the fruits of radicalisation since unquestioning allegiance was easy to achieve with curricula that portrayed the world in stark terms of good and evil.
But the radicalisation of madrassas should not lead us to give up in despair. In other parts of the world, madrassas have served an appropriate educational purpose. For example in West Bengal, India, a survey of Islamic schools in January 2009 found that because of the higher quality education at madrassas, even non-Muslims were actively enrolling in them. This was remarkably akin to how in Pakistan many Muslim families send their children to Christian schools because of the high quality of teaching and discipline.
Hindu enrolment in several Bengali madrassas, for example, was as high as 64 percent because many of these institutions offered vocational training programmes. Such examples can certainly be emulated in Pakistani madrassas as well. We should not give up on madrassas but rather help bring them back to their heyday of pluralistic learning.
The strategy of ‘draining the swamp’ by establishing sparkling government schools alongside madrassas, which appears to be the current approach from development donors, is likely to have limited success. Madrassas will immediately resort to a defensive strategy of labelling the government schools in conspiratorial terms and still be able to recruit students quite zealously from religious families. Investment to improve education is needed across Pakistan in all kinds of schools, including madrassas.
The only way to solve the madrassa problem is to engage in a process of reform that focuses on pluralism and conflict resolution skills that should be facilitated by the Pakistani government with the assistance of other Muslim countries and ulema.
There are already some positive moves from the ulema in Pakistan. Religious clerics from both the Deobandi Tablighi Jama’at and the Barelvi Sunni Tehreek have publicly rejected the Taliban approach to Islam. Madrassas such as the venerable Jamia Ashrafia in Lahore are now willing to initiate specific teaching modules that stress the importance of non-violence and respect for other faith traditions.
Momentum elsewhere towards such efforts is exemplified by reforms in places such as Indonesia’s Guluk-Guluk pesantren, where Islamic environmental education is being used to develop peace-building skills. During my visit to central Java last year, I visited several Islamic schools that are producing very balanced and employable young professionals. Indonesia, which is the world’s largest Muslim country, should share some of its success in improving madrassa curricula with Pakistan.
Where Western donors can help is to provide vocational training and apprenticeship programs for madrassa graduates that will be consistent with their religious values. Careers as healthcare apprentices and disaster relief professionals are particularly appropriate in this regard.
Although some of the radical madrassas will still need to be weeded out, embracing Islamic education with an integrated reform strategy is more likely to reduce militancy, rather than lamenting madrassas as arcane institutions to be eroded by naively creating an alternate market for schools.
Source
Labels: Islamist Parties, Islamization, Madrassas, Militants, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 10:04 AM,
,
![]()
Linked futures
Sunday, May 17, 2009
Analysis, Daily Times, Pakistan
Dr Hasan-Askari Rizvi
It is disappointing that some parties, especially the Islamists, cannot overcome their narrow partisan interests, which makes it difficult for them to fathom the gravest ever threat to Pakistan’s internal harmony and security
The on-going Swat operation is the most difficult internal security assignment for Pakistan’s security forces in a long time. The army is leading the operation with determination to re-establish the authority of state in the areas controlled by the Taliban. This will demonstrate if the Army has upgraded its counter-insurgency capacity. The outcome of this operation will also have implications for the future direction of Pakistani state and society. If this operation fails, it will weaken Pakistan’s resolve and capacity to engage in counter-insurgency in the tribal areas.
Withdrawal of the army and paramilitary forces without restoring the authority of the state is not an option; that would amount to surrendering Swat to the Taliban, and would encourage such elements elsewhere to pursue similar action against the state. This will also give impetus to various Islamist hard-liners in mainland Pakistan to impose their religious and cultural preferences on others.
Pakistan is engaged in an intense struggle to restore its soul, and faces the danger of being overwhelmed by religious and cultural extremism backed by violence. Given Pakistan’s regional, ethnic and cultural diversity, individuals and groups cannot be allowed to operate as self-styled vigilantes to enforce their socio-cultural and political preferences. That would not only destroy the fabric of Pakistani state and society but also invite external intervention by those who would like to contain the fallout from the ascendancy of extremists.
Read more
Labels: Islamist Parties, Islamization, Pakistan Army Operation, Swat Operation
posted @ 11:11 AM,
,
![]()
A cobweb of myths ( Prevelant in Pakistan)
Friday, May 15, 2009
Dr Tariq Rahman
Thursday, 14 May, 2009
NOW that a military operation is going on in the Malakand Division it is imperative that it should be supported by the people and that the IDPs should be looked after with all resources at hand and be treated with compassion and respect.
Unfortunately, we have many myths and conspiracy theories which prevent clear thinking and that need to be debunked.
Myth 1: America wants our nuclear weapons and is destabilising Pakistan through the Taliban.
....
Myth 2: Nothing gets done in Pakistan unless America wants it to happen.
.....
Myth 3: The Taliban want Islam in the country but their approach is wrong.
....
Myth 4: If Nato forces withdraw from Afghanistan there will be peace.
....
Myth 5: Islamic militancy is created by poverty and ignorance.
If we understand these and other myths and realise that we have created our own Frankensteins and not foreign countries; that most of the militants are our people and not foreigners (though some are); that foreign countries may help militants but are not powerful enough to keep them alive for ever; that we made mistakes in the past of which we are reaping the harvest — then we can still make Pakistan safe for our children.
Labels: Al Qaeda, Islamization, Osama Bin Laden, Pakistan, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 12:47 PM,
,
![]()
(Madrassahs) - A monstrous experiment
Monday, May 11, 2009
Monday, May 11, 2009
Nasir Abbas Mirza
Remote madrassas may be turning boys into drones but then there are thousands of madrassas spread all over Pakistan’s urban centres that are producing millions of neo-drones who may not become suicide bombers but are totally unfit to live in this world. These kids need to be rescued
Take a little boy and incarcerate him in a remote madrassa. Keep him far away from the rest of the world and bar any interaction with humanity. Indoctrinate him with a distorted version of a religion and tell him that he does not belong to this world. Teach him about the fanciful world that awaits him in the heaven, and that in order to attain that he has to destroy everything that stands in his way, including his own body.
By the time he is sixteen, the child would have become a drone: an un-manned man. Instead of a lively teenager, we would have a robot in living tissue ready to detonate on remote orders.
At full steam ahead in Pakistan, this is a monstrous experiment in brainwashing and it is on a par with, if not worse than, Nazi Germany’s eugenics. They did it in the name of science; here, it is being done in the name of God and religion. On a very large scale, this is a hugely successful experiment in which nurture triumphs and nature takes a beating.
Read more
Labels: Extremism, Islamization, Madrassas, Pakistan, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 5:59 PM,
,
![]()
War is hell
Monday, May 11, 2009
Syed Mansoor Hussain
The liberal and secular ethos is limited to a tiny minority. Most Pakistanis are not only beholden to religion in a big way but are intrinsically opposed to western style democracy and especially the freedoms that come with it
The fight against Taliban is at this time primarily a fight by the Pakistani state to enforce law and bring order to its territory. As such, all citizens of the country and those that wish Pakistan well must support the army in this effort to restore the ‘writ’ of the state. But that is not all this is about.
First what it is not about. It is not about the US or the drone attacks. It is not about India and Kashmir. It is not about the Taliban fighting the US and NATO forces in Afghanistan. And it is definitely not about the Bilderberg Group.
....
What Pakistan has seen since the death of Mohammad Ali Jinnah in 1948 is essentially a fight between competing visions of piety. For the first twenty years of its existence, Pakistan was under the sway of a ‘kinder and gentler’ version of Islamic practice as envisioned by the Sufi influenced Hanafi-Barelvi majority of the country.
Once General Zia-ul Haq took over and the Afghan war started, the religious centre of the country rapidly shifted under official patronage towards the more austere and extreme Wahhabi-Deobandi interpretation of Islam. The Taliban are a product of that interpretation and find support within the country from those that adhere to that vision of Islam even outside the border areas.
Even today, it was only after the religiously conservative political forces led by the PMLN and the organisations belonging to the Hanafi-Barelvi school came out against the Taliban that the Pakistan Army agreed to embark on a major offensive against the Taliban. I sincerely hope that this action is successful in restoring the rule of law in the disputed areas in Swat and eventually even in the western borderlands.
.....
The second point worth considering is that for the army to succeed, it needs the full support of the people. This can only happen if the religiously inclined people of Pakistan that oppose Taliban-style Islam are willing to come out openly and forcefully in support of the army. This, however, will have its own set of consequences.
Once the non-Taliban types are fully mobilised, what we will see is not necessarily a victory of secular democratic forces but rather of the Islamic ideation of a different mindset; but still very much Islamic and perhaps even equally extreme in its own way. I do not believe that Pakistan is headed towards an Iranian-style theocracy but we might not end up too far from it either.
Let us not forget that we came pretty close to having the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution (The Sharia Bill) just ten years ago, and the political party that wanted to pass it is, according to many, poised to take control of Pakistan come the next general elections. If that party does come to power in a few years and if the present military action has indeed spawned another lurch towards religious extremism, all bets are off as to what might happen next.
Read more
Labels: Extremism, Islamization, Pakistan, Taliban, Terrorism
posted @ 5:48 PM,
,
![]()


